Warning: Long post!
My experience has been mixed but I still shop there. One of the guys at night, maybe the one posting is great!
MF does not charge sales tax for Texas! That is a Big Big +1. Taxes really make some deals cost too much, especially for expensive items. Guitar Center on the other hand charges sales tax. The way someone from GC explained it, if they have a store in a state they have to charge tax, even for online purchases. Lol leave it to the government to screw us at every step! But the good news is MF does not. Plus the people on the phone at MF are much more knowledgable than GC on average.
My first experience with MF was buying a Fender Dlx Am PBass early this year. NO one had it yet. I called all over. MF gave me a discount because I had to wait. I was very impressed! I swapped it for a short scale Birdsong (another great bass!) with a Talkbass member recently. Called MF and they emailed me a receipt immediately so I could transfer the Fender warranty over! How nice!
But I tried recently to buy a Fender Artist Series Eric Clapton Strat with the recent Columbus Day discount they showed online. The code would not work online. I tried several times and gave up. I called around and could not match that advertised price.
Luckily I called MF and after a little bit of muddling through someone there applied the discount on the phone. I had talked with someone at GC and they were so confused I gave up and called MF, even though I did not think the Fender would be eligible for a discount.
Once I called MF the person stayed right in the process. I could tell they knew what to do, unlike the GC person.
From the conversations with the GC people I am still confused whether Fender participates in sales for some of their gear lol! But MF did right by me. It was just odd that I could not apply the online code. But since I could not find anyone selling that cheap, that had the exact model I wanted I called MF. I almost didnt since the website would not apply the discount and the GC person got me so confused. But it is a good thing I called! I LOVE this Stratocaster. If anyone plays guitar also, it's the Blackie one.
A day or two after I ordered the Strat I ordered a Fender Mustang practice amp. (In case you dont know, it is a Very cool 99 dollar practice amp with all sort of different effects! Love this little jewel!) I think it cost me 85 dollars with the discount. Well worth it. The MF website said the Columbus day 15% offer was extended. Same problem. Tried ordering the amp and the discount would not apply online. Another call and problem solved. Person was very good, applied the discount. Amp on the way.
Back to the story. I got the amp. Then about a week later I ordered a few little things, nothing much and I did it online. I checked my email after a couple of hours and there was another amp on it also! I am guessing that because I had tried to order the amp before it showed up on my online order, although I did not notice it in my cart. It may have still been there and I overlooked it. Hm... I guess I will never know.
I called MF immediately. The young lady was nice but said it had already shipped.... Lol this was late at night! She said tell UPS I refused the package. Unfortunately I was not home. My UPS guy is fantastic and left it for me because I have given them written permission and no one can see stuff on my porch, my neighbors would make it really rough on anyone trying to steal here etc.
So... I had to call back. Now I am waiting for a return authorization and going to take it to the UPS store and drop it off myself.
Bottom line, MF has saved me money and I like them. They will still be the first place I call. But I have had two problems, one being the Columbus day code that would not apply on their website, which they fixed with a call, the other somehow getting the second amp I did not order, which they were also helpful with.
Musician's Friend is a good place. I hope they do business the same way a long time!
Sorry for the long post, but they have saved me hundreds of dollars, done the best they could and I feel they deserve some praise.