• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

What Makes an Excellent Bassist?

I might parse it out a bit -

Strong knowledge of music theory helps you be a better musician. It allows you to understand a song and learn it more quickly and accurately, or to compose more creatively and efficiently.

There are a lot of things that make you a better band member. Things like listening to the rest of the band, being prepared, having a due mix of self-respect and humility, contributing to the project, and general professionalism.

As far as what makes an excellent bassist, specifically, others have mentioned these, but I'd say: one is technique. Early on, as a beginner just starting to jam with people, I made a resolution that I never wanted to be the guy who would veto a song choice because I didn't have the chops to play it. I still can't do Jaco or Wooten, and have soft spots in my abilities, but there's never NOT a reason to improve your chops and your flexibility to move between styles. (This could also have been counted as being a better musician generally, not just a bassist, but I mean drilling technique on bass, being able to play well fingerstyle or pick or slap, etc.).

The other is groove. If a song is a body, then (in most popular genres) the percussion builds a skeleton, and the bass is what puts muscle on those bones and makes them move in their own distinctive way. Most other instruments and vocals are the kind of outer things - skin, hair, eyes, etc. - that catch the eye., but have to have that bone-and-muscle understructure to lie over or they're not attractive. So learning how to lock in with the percussion (the "pocket") and create a smooth and supple movement for the rest of the band to stretch over is key.
 
good music.

to really get deep, i'd say you also need a physical technique that is sustainable so you can play without developing wrist / hand problems?

but great music comes from great musicians, and even worse is that "Great" is subjective.
 
Question to famous musician who was yelling out chord changes during the set to his regular bass player:
Q: Why on earth do you play with this guy?
A: Yes but he has a car
So there
 

Attachments

  • lebaron-2.jpg
    lebaron-2.jpg
    49.4 KB · Views: 31
  • Like
Reactions: hrodbert696
This may sound counter-intuitive, but some of the best musicians I know and have played with are the ones you forget are there. They are so in the music and foundation that your dependence on them or their parts is invisible. They are never the focus at practices or performances because they are doing exactly what they and everyone else intends to the point where they are taken for granted. When you realize that of your fellow players that is when you tell them how good they are. They most often are not playing for themselves but for the music itself, and so indirectly for the whole group. These are also most often the players who show up on time, know the material in and out, are fairly quiet, and simply bring everything they can to the table without seeking anything back other than the rewards of being a solid contribution.
 
This has been on my mind and so I have decided to ask TalkBass members for their thoughts and or opinions on what makes an excellent Bassist. Knowledge of the instrument, technique and musical theory are three things that may play a part but, what do you think makes an excellent bass player?
IMO show up on time, know the material, don't step on toes and get along with the other guys/gals is as important as being an "excellent" bassist.

They knew what you had when they ask you. The longer you play together the rest will come.
 
Last edited: