• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

What would you do??

fourstringbliss

Supporting Member
Oct 5, 2003
12,442
6,016
56
Puyallup, WA
Excuse me ahead of time for a bit of a long story. I want you to understand the context of my situation...:D

I've got an Ibanez BTB 510E that I've modified with an Audere Classic 4-Band preamp and Nordstrand Big Splits.

Picture002-1.jpg


It's a great sounding bass, especially strung like it is with TI flats, and I can cop a pretty good Jazz Bass tone by boosting lows/highs and cutting high mids/low mids.

I then bought an MIM fretless Fender Jazz and proceeded to replace the bridge, pickups, tuners, and install an Audere JZ5D preamp into it. I then discovered that fretless is not my thing so I decided to trade the neck for a fretted one and had planned on refininshing it. Finally I decided to replace the body and make my own parts Jazz, and right now I'm only missing the body and neck.

I've always liked the sound I get from older American Sterlings and also wanted to get myself one of those, and then it hit me - I could install a Nordstrand MM pup in between the Big Splits and, according to Carey Nordstrand, get a pretty good MM sound, plus the MM and the BS's would sound different enough to make it worth doing. I'm going to wire the BS's to a pickup selector switch and then to the pre as the "neck" pickup and the MM to a series/single-coil/parallel switch and then to the pre as the "bridge" pickup. I can then blend the two in any combination I want. I don't have the money to do this project at this time, though. It would look something like this when it's finished:

ScreenShot002-2.gif


This brings me to the parts Jazz. Since I can already cop a nice Jazzish tone I'm afraid that I'm going to put $700+ into a bass that I'm not going to play that much - I can't justify having a bass for the sake of having a bass. I could finish the Jazz, which would be a very nice bass with all the parts that I've got, or I could sell them off, do the BTB MM pup project, and buy a cheaper P-Bass, which is about the only fretted tone I couldn't get from the BTB with the added MM pup.

I'm not a pro and don't record, so I don't need exactly a jazz bass tone. What would you do in this situation?
 
I like that second situation selling the jazz off,and getting a P. I wonder how massive that BTB would sound if you just routed out the original pickup areas and put two MM buckers for an HH model.

I'll bet the BTB would sound huge with two MM's but I really like the sound of the Big Splits. I'm exicted about the prospect of have an old-school MM pup in there. I'm not into the sound of any new Stingry/Sterling that I've played but the older ones sound great to me - more open and detailed, less thick and aggressive. Carey Nordstrand basically reverse engineered a pre-EBMM MM pickup and it's supposed to be all old-school Stingray/Sterling tone.