• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

What's your writing process?

ffutterman

Talentless Bass Enthusiast
May 7, 2010
1,006
130
Philadelphia
As strange as it is, getting a cheap banjo turned out to be a major catalyst for my music writing (I'm using the term loosely).

I hadn't really written music before, but I started messing around with the banjo and hit a bunch of those "Wow, that sounded cool!" moments. I'd write those out in Guitar Pro (so I wouldn't forget them), and without knowing much about music theory, I'd sort of hear what chord I wanted to use next and go from there. Pretty soon, I'd have a simple progression, but when I would go back to listen to it, I would hear (in my head) a bass line that I wanted to use.

That seems to be what works best for me: Grab the banjo or uke, goof around til I come up with chords I like, then write a bass line for that.

So now I'm kind of wondering how other people approach writing. What's your process?
 
It varies, of course, but I tend to start with chords and melody first. Often a chord progression suggests a melody, which I fill out with some nonsense phrasing until I figure out what the song's about. Then I write a drum part. The bassline comes after all that, then any other ancillary instruments/filligree.

That's the nutshell version. In reality, it's usually a very messy process, with step 3 intruding on step 2, which is revisited in step 5, which in turn has already intruded on step 1....
 
I usually put on a CD with music in the same style as I feel like writing. Then I start playing random note structures (I don't know theory, so excuse when I use technical terms inappropiately) until I hit something I like. When that happens, I remember the line and start playing variations to see whether it could be done better.

For me, it usually starts with the bass line, and I work from there.
 
I'll usually start by writing random ideas in Finale Notepad, or Musescore, using the piano sound. You can change instruments later to see how it sounds.
If I have an idea for a bass line, I'll work it out on bass first, then notate it in the program. Once I hear what's going on there, I'll add instruments and go from there.
If I'm writing lyrics, I come up with the melody first, and work everything else out from there.