• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Where the Fretless Ps at?

The all passive P5 with just a split PU and a roasted maple neck can be ordered as fretless, too, but they seem harder to get. They do not offer unlined necks. AFAIK, several American members of the "Sire club" have ordered Sire basses and guitars from Thomann/Germany, as that was easier/cheaper than from local distributors. Anderton's/UK are also a huge Sire distributor, so there's that.
Oh, sweet. Thanks for the info! I’ll look into the P5
 
Here’s my 1970 first year factory fretless. All original except a fretboard epoxy done by the great HG Thor. Picked it up right here on TB during the pandemic. And no, I don’t think I’d ever let it go.
 

Attachments

  • E20E0CF8-186E-4ACB-9D3B-FE59FFA7888B.jpeg
    E20E0CF8-186E-4ACB-9D3B-FE59FFA7888B.jpeg
    380.9 KB · Views: 40
Possibly, but if so, that happened in the last 25 years.
Fender seemed clueless in the 70s & 80s as to Jaco's influence.


I'm curious what year Fender 1st offered a US production Jazz.
In '94, I picked up a mij fretless Jazz at the Bass Place while in AZ.
That was the 1st time I'd seen any production fretless Jazz.
in '99 or '2000, I became aware of the Jaco Signature & Custom Shop offerings, and I ordered the Custom Shop. IIRC, they still didn't offer a US production Jazz at that time.



Back to "where's all the fretless Ps / where have all the good time gone"?

View attachment 4973576

Looks like ‘97 or so before first fretless Jazz, according to my history of Fender book.

9899C237-78CB-40E3-A8C4-3864DC8854AA.jpeg
 
The very best P bass I’ve ever owned, a mash-up of assorted parts I had hanging around in boxes and drawers. The neck is a ‘70’s Tokai, the body is of an unknown origin but most likely Asian (Korea or China) and everything else is just spare parts … I think the pickups are from an older SX, but not sure. I wouldn’t sell it for anything.
D287F325-CE5D-44A6-8C1A-139CB89279F9.jpeg
 
Another in the build your own camp. I bought a Squier CV 60's P used for $180 and added an allparts neck with an unlined ebony board. I never have been comfortable with narrow width necks and this vintage profile neck in tinted laquer feels like home. I went for Gotoh lollipops instead of reusing the squier tuning pegs so the all in cost was just under $600. I love the way the bass feels and often get compliments on the sound.
IMG_5126.jpg
 
I've moved my Squier fretless back and forth between a P and J body. I greatly prefer the sound of the P with fretless. Mwah ain't my thing. I like the little subtle muting and finger sounds you can get with fretless, and the P pickup seems to bring those out.
Yeah, I’m the same way!

Don’t get me wrong, having a fretless Jazz (or something with a nice bridge pickup) is nice for some stuff (like learning melodies/solos), but I love a P as my main player - for both fretted and fretless instruments.

I am also a very big fan of the simplicity of a P, which is largely why I don’t want a PJ if I can help it
 
Yes, it’s technically an oxymoron — but years before Jaco — Fender first released the fretless P (circa 1970). They waited years to release a fretless J.

View attachment 4973397

I did not know that. I would have assumed that the fretless Jazz would have preceded the fretless Precision. Thanks for posting this info!

I just read this article and I wonder how accurate it is???

A quick history of the fretless bass | Guitar World

Intriguingly, it seems that no-one actually knows for a fact when the first electric bass was actually defretted. However, the most likely theory is that the earliest fretless player to receive much widespread attention was Bill Wyman of the Rolling Stones, who played a home-made fretless as early as 1961, when Pastorius was only 10 years old. It began life as a standard fretted instrument, as the laconic four-stringer revealed in an interview some years ago: "I was playing in an R&B band in 1961 when I bought [the bass] from this guy our drummer knew. Before that I'd been playing bass on the bottom two strings of a detuned guitar, so I was glad to finally have a 'real' bass. Unfortunately, it was bloody horrible!… it rattled with every note because the frets were so worn. I figured I'd just pull out all the frets and put in new ones when I could afford some. But when I pulled 'em out, it suddenly sounded really good! So I never put frets back in, and I think it was the first fretless electric ever. I used it on every Stones album and many of the singles up to 1975. Even without an amp, it sounds wonderful — it's got the sound."
 
So many cool fretless P basses!!! As I described earlier, here is mine: Allparts build purchased from TBr 4Mal.

I was actually looking for a fretless J (and had some sort of unfounded negative bias toward fretless Ps, probably because Jaco) But I talked myself into it and I am glad I took the plunge.

Lined ebony board (w/ dots), Fralin pick up, hipshot tuners, TI flats, under $500.

new PG courtesy Stratosphere $10

Oldschool thump and warm organic furry P vibe = priceless

ABEB372C-C621-46A9-A083-807C09BA4134.jpeg