• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join free Log in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Which Bass guitar would you record with

#161
Clark W said:
I own 7 basses. Of those, 5 are Fender. My #1 is an American Performer Precision P/J with no grease bucket tone circuit, and Aguilar's hum canceling PJ pup set. It's what I would normally record with, but... I recently re strung one of my Jazz basses with half rounds. I used it this past Sunday in a full band setting, working on an original that we want to record. If I were to record that song tomorrow, it would be with that Jazz and not my PJ.
Click to expand...
My favorite bass to record with is a 1961 custom shop jazz bass with stacked concentric knobs. The tonal possibilities are endless
 
  • Like
Reactions: Clark W
#163
I’m a P Bass convert - the perfect tone for me, especially recording.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_1622.jpeg
    IMG_1622.jpeg
    1 MB · Views: 18
  • Like
Reactions: PleyswethSqwerl
#165
PleyswethSqwerl said:
My favorite bass to record with is a 1961 custom shop jazz bass with stacked concentric knobs. The tonal possibilities are endless
Click to expand...
Stacked concentric knobs should be the standard on any Fender bass that has two pups with seperate volume controls. I wished my Jazzes had them. It just makes sense.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LadyLoveStingRay5 and PleyswethSqwerl
#172
My own FrankenFenduier - a bass I assembled myself with a Fender MIM body, Squier maple neck, full EMG electronics package:
Want a J-sound: full bridge pickup
Want a P-sound: full neck pickup
Want a MM-sound: blend the bridge pickups with a bit of neck-pickup.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PleyswethSqwerl
#175
Clearly a P/J bass or random boutique bass for versatility.
Because if you don't know the style of music, choose versatility and kick in the nuts who ever say versatility means not great at everything.

Example:
I'm playing for the Drums club and the French music day at my work and we're are playing many styles of music on one gig.
Reggae, Rock, Alternative, Old School Jazz, Pop, classic Rock, 80', 90' ...
I need to have a agressive tone on one song and a motown tone on the next. No pedals, One amp.
My bass (PU configuration, active preamp) and finger placement is enough to switch between all that = Versatility
Not that i'm that good, just i'm there to enjoy and serve music.

P basses, MM, RIckenbacker.... No.
J basses... maybe.
 
#176
BoogieZK said:
Clearly a P/J bass or random boutique bass for versatility.
Because if you don't know the style of music, choose versatility and kick in the nuts who ever say versatility means not great at everything.

Example:
I'm playing for the Drums club and the French music day at my work and we're are playing many styles of music on one gig.
Reggae, Rock, Alternative, Old School Jazz, Pop, classic Rock, 80', 90' ...
I need to have a agressive tone on one song and a motown tone on the next. No pedals, One amp.
My bass (PU configuration, active preamp) and finger placement is enough to switch between all that = Versatility
Not that i'm that good, just i'm there to enjoy and serve music.

P basses, MM, RIckenbacker.... No.
J basses... maybe.
Click to expand...

I do like the PJ configurational I think a 61 jazz bass stacked knobs solves all those problems also
 
#178
BoogieZK said:
Clearly a P/J bass or random boutique bass for versatility.
Because if you don't know the style of music, choose versatility and kick in the nuts who ever say versatility means not great at everything.

Example:
I'm playing for the Drums club and the French music day at my work and we're are playing many styles of music on one gig.
Reggae, Rock, Alternative, Old School Jazz, Pop, classic Rock, 80', 90' ...
I need to have a agressive tone on one song and a motown tone on the next. No pedals, One amp.
My bass (PU configuration, active preamp) and finger placement is enough to switch between all that = Versatility
Not that i'm that good, just i'm there to enjoy and serve music.

P basses, MM, RIckenbacker.... No.
J basses... maybe.
Click to expand...

Is there a reason pedals aren't allowed?
 
#179
PleyswethSqwerl said:
If you all had one bass guitar that you absolutely had to record your album with. Which one would you choose?

1. Precision Bass (PBass).
2. Jazz Bass (JBass).
3. Musicman Stingray.
4. Rickenbavker.
5. P/J.
6. Some other brand or miscellaneous
Bass.

I’m curious to hear other bassist responses. And, Why? they would choose that specific bass if they could only choose that one.
Click to expand...
Ibanez SR600E
 
#180
PleyswethSqwerl said:
The material is whatever “your” music is that you are writing for your album as written in the post and, the bass that “you” would choose.
Click to expand...
I’m so sorry, I’ll make sure my next post is more helpful for answering this burning and important question.

I have three P basses, two Rays, a fretless Jazz, plus a few others you haven’t mentioned here. Each Precision is very different from the other, in my opinion, because of how they sound and how they inspire me to play, but I’m being asked to make a choice between models, not between P basses.

One inspires me to play more aggressively, one more restrained with attack and laid back and consistent with phrasing, and one more busy. And that’s just the P basses.

I don’t write songs, I come up with the bass lines where someone else has provided the structure, melody, and general feel. I rely on variety.

So I stand by my original answer, but I hope that this expanded version makes your day.
 
Last edited:

Latest posts

Top Bottom
Back