Try re-eqing without the pedal first. Take everything back to flat bring the gain up to right before clipping the add a touch of mid & hi mid. If it's still too round the roll back a bit of bottom off it. Remember small changes in EQ make big changes in sound. Also dial in with your ears not your eyes. IF you can find a usable tone then bring the pedal back into the mix using same idea ie: a little goes a long way. If that does not help then ya sell it all and start over. Ant excuse for new rear, right? 
