• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Which of These Stingrays Would You Recommend?

Which Stingray would you recommend?

  • Old Smoothie

    Votes: 36 25.5%
  • Stingray Special 4HH

    Votes: 60 42.6%
  • Tim Commerford Passive Long Scale

    Votes: 21 14.9%
  • I hate Stingrays

    Votes: 6 4.3%
  • Carrots

    Votes: 18 12.8%

  • Total voters
    141
Are you talking about the Sterling by Music Man basses made in Indonesia or the EBMM Sterling basses made in the USA? I'm pretty sure amcory is talking about the later.
I have tried both the MIA Sterling and the Indonesian version and both of them were a long way off sounding like a true Stingray. Certain characteristics were there but overall it is better to fork out the extra for a proper Ray.
 
The EBMM Sterling is meant to be a different instrument than the Stingray just like the Bongo.
Yes I know that and it's just a pity that other people cannot grasp that fact because a lot of people think that you can get the same tone and sound out of a Sterling the same as you can out of a EB Stingray. It ain't happening.Personally I would opt for Pre EB Stingray obviously 2 band, but these are hard to come by so the next nearest would be a Classic which isn't as warm and dark as an Old Smoothie, but also doesn't have the zing and hi fi tone of a 3 band.
 
Yes I know that and it's just a pity that other people cannot grasp that fact because a lot of people think that you can get the same tone and sound out of a Sterling the same as you can out of a EB Stingray. It ain't happening.
That's like wanting an SG to sound like a Les Paul just because they're both Gibson, have 2 humbucking pickups, and set necks. With enough distortion, I suppose.
 
That's like wanting an SG to sound like a Les Paul just because they're both Gibson, have 2 humbucking pickups, and set necks. With enough distortion, I suppose.
I know the same goes for the Special with endless owners stating that they can get it to sound like a 2 band which is not possible due to its components. Basically EB no longer currently provide an original sounding Stingray with that special tone which is very sad, unless you can get your hands on a Cliff Williams model but the problem there is that there where only 26 made.
 
I'm curious; what do the new Stingrays sound like?

How does the tone differ?
There's a bunch of threads about the Specials that you could look up. Also plenty of pro level demo vids on YouTube. To my ears they are more mid/treble present which gives the whole sound a balanced tone. The 3-band EQ is amazing. The broad frequency mid-freq band has a huge range. I love pushing the bass and lowering the treb/mid for reggae tunes. The bass always sounds like a ray. IMHO, I was never a huge Ray fan before the specials. I thought they sounded way too scooped and if you cut the treble then the bass was just mushy. But the specials are my #1.

anyways, my two cents.
 
I know the same goes for the Special with endless owners stating that they can get it to sound like a 2 band which is not possible due to its components. Basically EB no longer currently provide an original sounding Stingray with that special tone which is very sad, unless you can get your hands on a Cliff Williams model but the problem there is that there where only 26 made.
One can buy a Cliff Williams model right now from various places including MF. The problem is that they are way too expensive at $7000.00 apiece.
 
One can buy a Cliff Williams model right now from various places including MF. The problem is that they are way too expensive at $7000.00 apiece.
That is way too expensive, you can get a Pre EB for less than that but that would depend on if you like that kind of tone. Some prefer 2 band some prefer 3, some prefer H and some prefer HH it is each to their own. Which ever model you prefer you can be assured that it will be well made, and that is what binds them all together.
 
Stingray owner here.

Without doubt or hesitance, get the Old Smoothie.

I love my Stingray more than any of my other basses, but the five times I played an Old Smoothie, the same Old Smoothie, I fell in love with it equally.

Some people say that Stingrays have too much "Zing", and I know what they mean.

But, to me, an Old Smoothie has much less of that "Zing," and sits very comfortably between a regular Stingray and a Jazz bass.

Warm for a Stingray, hot for a Jazz.
My Stingray.
View attachment 4361613

interesting finish. Or is it just the lighting of the photo (my phone?)
 
interesting finish. Or is it just the lighting of the photo (my phone?)
Jeff100 are you referring to my Stingray?
It's just standard black.
I took the picture with my Pentax camera and a good lens.
The bass had just been set up and cleaned when the photo was taken.
Would you like to see a few more photos?

Mike
 
Ok, a few more Stingray photos.
Stingray on a wicker couch. Boring.
IMGP6887.jpg

Add a point of interest and some color - better picture. Mickey makes things better.
IMGP6888.jpg

On a picnic table.Color.
IMGP6863.jpg

Black & White.
IMGP6902.jpg

Close up.
IMGP6862.jpg

I did three things to create these pictures.
1.) Used a good camera and lens.
2.) Used a tripod.
3.) Metered the light carefully.
Mike ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Roger W
I played an OLP once so I am not qualified to even post here. But regarding the topic I will to say, I really like the look of that Old Smoothie in Butterscotch. Oh, and deep in my ever en-feebling mind, there is a logic to those big poles lying either side of the strings.

Really, I want to offer my best with the challenge and wish you all the best on the road ahead.

(PS I've been known to stash a Thermos flask and a cup of tea behind my amp at gigs and it can be very refreshing.)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Roger W
Jeff100 are you referring to my Stingray?
It's just standard black.
I took the picture with my Pentax camera and a good lens.
The bass had just been set up and cleaned when the photo was taken.
Would you like to see a few more photos?

Mike

Its light reflections- in the first photo you posted, caused the illusion of a two toned bass, IE looking like the top was gloss black and the sides / back / beveled section were a navy blue. Then the gloss black was picking up a woodgrain look from perhaps an adjacent structure? Gloss will act as a mirror like that.

In either case, I thought it looked pretty cool, especially if it were a two tone finish in solid colors like that.

Nice bass in either case!

Hats off for using a tripod and metering. I used to use a tripod and cable release allot.
I haven't been doing as much serious photography recent years though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Michael Jewels