• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Which Would You buy?

Which bass would you buy? (Pick 3)

  • USA Fender Geddy Lee Jazz

    Votes: 99 31.8%
  • Dingwall D-Roc

    Votes: 44 14.1%
  • G&L Kiloton

    Votes: 106 34.1%
  • Warrior Messenger

    Votes: 34 10.9%
  • Fender American Ultra Precision

    Votes: 101 32.5%
  • Roscoe Classic Custom 4JJ

    Votes: 53 17.0%
  • Fender American Elite Jazz

    Votes: 73 23.5%
  • Dingwall Combustion 4

    Votes: 78 25.1%

  • Total voters
    311
I am interested in a new everyday driver bass. I play some rock and metal in the studio for recording and also play in a cover band doing 90's rock and R&B. I usually play Ibanez basses but want to upgrade. Here are the main basses I am looking at, all of them are comparable in pricing on Reverb currently. I just can't decide! They all seem to have their pros and cons, and unfortunately, they aren't close for me to test them in person. What would you buy? I know there are a ton of Fender players so I expect the Fenders will get higher responses. I am leading towards the Warrior Messenger, but then it is an active bass and I was originally going to go for a passive bass, but the Warrior is so light and awesome sound. I just don't know, I could make a case for any of these. I am tempted to learn the fanned fret but also scared it will mess with my playing so I am nervous about the Dingwalls but I know they are amazing basses. The Roscoe and the Warrior are both like something of a level I never thought I could afford but there is one of each in my price range. Love to hear your thoughts!
I've known players that put their Ibanez above their Fender. Which one do you have that needs upgrading? I would buy anything from your list.
 
Coincidentally, I tried the D-Roc and the Kiloton at my local shop at the weekend. I'd not played anything with fanned frets before, hence trying the D-Roc. I found it to be a lot easier than I thought it would be. Looking down, I could obviously see the frets were differently laid out but my fingers just seemed to naturally go to the right place. Darndest thing, it didn't feel any different than playing my normal basses. I suspect some kind of sorcery. Anyway, I couldn't get any output from the D-Roc (either the batteries were dead or there's an on-switch I couldn't see) and there was no assistant handy, so I looked round and saw this cherry red Kiloton hanging on the wall.
A G&L is on my B GAS list and I've been leaning towards an blue burst L-2000 (I already have a 4H Stingray, so this felt like a natural progression). Darndest thing: part II though was I ended up falling a little bit in love with the Kiloton. It was comfortable to hold and play, it sounded really nice; also the passive electronics, satin neck, maple fretboard, block inlays (probably stickers but ok with that) all tick my boxes. Seriously, I could have sat there and played it all day and if I'd had £399 on me, I'd have walked out with it. I'd been on the lookout for a replacement for my old ATK 300 and it looks like I've found it. On with the saving up... :)
 
Last edited:
1. The American Geddy Lee Jazz Bass is on the top of your list.
2. The Geddy Lee Jazz Bass is probably the best Jazz Bass Fender has ever made.
3. See #1.

I’m with you on #2. At the intro, I think it was $1500 USD. Compared to other US Fenders, it would be my buy. I could be wrong but the $$ went up pretty fast. Don’t understand when you look at Fender site so many basses not in stock… seems like they never are ???? Oh well, I have as many as I need.
 
I am interested in a new everyday driver bass. I play some rock and metal in the studio for recording and also play in a cover band doing 90's rock and R&B. I usually play Ibanez basses but want to upgrade. Here are the main basses I am looking at, all of them are comparable in pricing on Reverb currently. I just can't decide! They all seem to have their pros and cons, and unfortunately, they aren't close for me to test them in person. What would you buy? I know there are a ton of Fender players so I expect the Fenders will get higher responses. I am leading towards the Warrior Messenger, but then it is an active bass and I was originally going to go for a passive bass, but the Warrior is so light and awesome sound. I just don't know, I could make a case for any of these. I am tempted to learn the fanned fret but also scared it will mess with my playing so I am nervous about the Dingwalls but I know they are amazing basses. The Roscoe and the Warrior are both like something of a level I never thought I could afford but there is one of each in my price range. Love to hear your thoughts!

I love my G&L Kiloton.
Sleek body design, super-comfortable.
And that MFD pickup in series mode is super super loud - I keep it at about 7/10 in series. Wide open is overkill. Also, the single coil gives a nice crisp sound, and parallel approximates of a J bass with both pickups on full.
I think these Kilotons are versatile and way underappreciated.
 
  • Like
Reactions: coyoteboy
I am interested in a new everyday driver bass. I play some rock and metal in the studio for recording and also play in a cover band doing 90's rock and R&B. I usually play Ibanez basses but want to upgrade. Here are the main basses I am looking at, all of them are comparable in pricing on Reverb currently. I just can't decide! They all seem to have their pros and cons, and unfortunately, they aren't close for me to test them in person. What would you buy? I know there are a ton of Fender players so I expect the Fenders will get higher responses. I am leading towards the Warrior Messenger, but then it is an active bass and I was originally going to go for a passive bass, but the Warrior is so light and awesome sound. I just don't know, I could make a case for any of these. I am tempted to learn the fanned fret but also scared it will mess with my playing so I am nervous about the Dingwalls but I know they are amazing basses. The Roscoe and the Warrior are both like something of a level I never thought I could afford but there is one of each in my price range. Love to hear your thoughts!
A G&L Kiloton and a Warrior Messenger both made your short list, but no Stingray?

I got a Stingray earlier this year, and I've been kicking myself everyday since then for not getting one sooner. Maybe it's a little out of your budget, but they're really killer basses!

Of the basses you have listed, I'd personally go with the Warrior just because it's Stingray-ish, and it's unique.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JBoogy
never heard of a warrior messenger bass. now that i have what are they thinking with that pickguard?
messenger-05.jpg


 
The way the neck feels is a big deal to me. I don't know your whole list, but I do know what a G&L and what a Fender would feel like to play in comparison to an Ibanez. Ibanez tends to have tighter spacing, and can have a flatter or even compound radius with a narrow nut width, which will feel different from a 9.5" radius with a little wider nut width. So, tone a bass can can produce aside, how it feels when you play it could either positively or negatively impact how you feel about said bass...
Having said that, the G&L would be my pick. Now I'm an FSO (Fender Shaped Object) passive player, so I'm going to gravitate to that neck profile and am going to favor the P-Bass w/flats tone, so out of that list, of course I'm going to pick the G&L... I like how there is a series/single-coil/parallel switch onboard. I think I could cover the genres/types of music you mentioned with one. Especially if used with some kind of active preamp like maybe a sansamp bass DI. - One thing to watch out for on the Kilotons they can go heavy and I'll bet that Ibanez you've been used to is pretty light. Weight might be one more thing to consider.
 
  • Current USA Fenders are overpriced IMO, so if I wanted a high end J bass I might consider that Roscoe just out of spite. But I vastly prefer a P bass, generally speaking. So eliminate all Jazz basses and USA Fenders.
  • D-Roc and Warrior are a very different aesthetic from the typical Fender-shaped "standard". If that works for you, great. But it's a non-starter for me personally.
  • I am curious about G&L, but I'm not sure that a Kiloton would be my first choice over a L-2000 or SB-2.
So that narrows it down to the Dingwall Combustion. :)
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: MachMike and JBoogy