• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Who makes a great J right now?

Your first-choice J-style bass would be:

  • Fender / Custom Shop

    Votes: 175 34.0%
  • Sadowsky

    Votes: 102 19.8%
  • Lakland

    Votes: 44 8.6%
  • Lull

    Votes: 27 5.3%
  • Other

    Votes: 166 32.3%

  • Total voters
    514
Brady Muckelroy makes his version of a J. Contact him through Facebook or through his website: Link Removed
Entirely handmade, customizable to your specs, and hands down, the best basses I've ever played. I own two of his HMC models, and am just floored by the sound, feel and biild quality.
 
  • Like
Reactions: pachoate
Well I happen to think that anything Jazz with quality and value has to lead you to Nino Valenti. I got mine a few months ago and it is an absolute dream to play. My brother and I are born again players. His fantasy was a Les Paul; we paid the same money. Mine is admittedly, by him and myself, far superior in build quality and attention to detail. Mine plays like butter, had tone to die for and looks beautiful. Nino will make you whatever you want. I picked it up at his house and he is a really good and supportive builder.
As a born again player I take bass lessons and my bass teacher plays it himself for the last 5 minutes of our lesson. Check out his site and check out the TALKBASS classifieds for used ones. Can't go wrong.
 
Elite and the American Original are very high on my list to try. Can't get away right now—working my ass off.
I thought long and hard about getting an American Elite before I pulled the trigger on a Sire v7 Vintage 5 String.
I initally went with this because it was going to be my first 5 string, and I really wanted the 70's pickup spacing... Well I'm super glad i "settled" for a Sire v7 Vintage, I've played Elites before and i prefer the v7 Vintage sound... and it's really not even close.

Can't say enough awesome things about it. Another bass player actually thought it was a Fender Elite after playing a set with it and never looking at the head stock, and that dude was a bamf!
 
This thread is to become an endless treadmill on personal favorings ...
Imagine all the time applied in practicing; that's where the good bassists spring out!
Ehm, did i mention a Steinberger XL2 ... and all's solved for once & forever.
Btw, i had a lotta Ps, and never really liked the JBs though.
 
I am completely biased (*disclaimer*) but I love my Marco TFL (completely handmade in the USA by a master luthier starting at $1600). The N1 series is also amazing (more classic with 34" scale, starting at only $1200). And his handwound pickups are downright incredible (you can get a very "active" sound even in passive mode, or roll the tone off for a more vintage feel). Here's some pics, and feel free to reach out to me any time with any questions on these!!

white RNR Block inlays.jpg IMG_9583.JPG 19030765_1430305847004890_6415076357000836812_n.jpg 34385973_1777780988924039_5660916339515064320_n.jpg s-l1600 (4).jpg Gold N1 close up copy.jpg Black N1.jpg 21192062_1507342665967874_3633143356263730108_n.jpg Surf Trans Back Body.jpg Red Transparent N1.jpg 28827306_1695517763817029_63852136979675537_o.jpg 14485063_1171796329522511_8669487447543390278_n.jpg
 
2018-06-28 23.59.52.jpg

Please, nobody should think I mean "the best," I simply mean, "whose J should I be trying out?".

Looking for a (potentially new) Jazz (could be Fender, could be someone else) in the following configuration:

Ash body
Maple neck
wider 70's pickup spacing
Not necessary, but active EQ could be nice.

My son owns the Sire Marcus Miller J (60's style) and I'm pretty amazed how great that bass plays and sounds, particularly for the $$. I'd be happy with one of those, but I'm looking for something with a higher level of craftsmanship that will age well.

How are Laklands in the post-Dan Lakin era? I have an older Skyline Glaub that's just the best.

Thanks for suggestions.
I bought a Marcus Miller P7 bass and I am very happy with it. It is very comparable to the $2,000 Fender Jazz Bass. Mine has the Ash body, Maple neck with block inlays (that do not look like black electricians tape) and is 18 volt active.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Luigir
even after getting what may be the most bottom out of my L2KT it's still like a J on steroids, same with my Fender Power Jazz Bass Special, they're both fine and inexpensive basses with great potential beyond the J aspects. another superb J is the Cort Curbow Retro, yet gives out a lot of bottom as well via the mid J PU, they too go cheap but are quality basses. the caveat, two of these are not made now. or a Washburn T24 Taurus.
 
You might consider G&L.
Nothing against Fender, I own a very nice P bass and a superb Squier VM Jazz, but even though I might come across some other good basses, G&L is the only one I check for every day at reverb and other sites.
However, no one, NO ONE, gives you as many options as Bacchus.
View attachment 3125852

I would avoid g&l. If you want a standard jazz then try one. If you start getting into an L series you're rolling the dice in my opinion.

This is not a knock on the OP or g&l, I just haven't had a great experience.

I just picked up a reasonably priced Warwick $$ with a swamp ash body. That was sort of a rare find.

One thing I might reccomend, and I know I'm late to the game so someone probably suggested this, but maybe you should look at a Corvette standard with jazz pickups. You can find early 2000s on Ebay for good deals. I have had nothing but good luck and good quality for what is becoming vintage by date.

The only problem is that they are usually bubinga which ways a ton. The sound and the neck are worth it.

I have also been looking at the sires. I think they may be the best value. On another note, if you want a serviceable bass for a reasonable price there is a brand called Wolf. I have a 6 string 3 band and it plays very nicely for the price.

Hope this helps.
 
Well, I figure this. No bass luthier or manufacture makes the best. It's really how well you play to make that instrument do and sound what your exactly looking for. I mean,...woods, preamps, pickups, strings fretboard material, amps, preamps, effect pedals, room ambience, etc. The list can go on. Look, Marcus Miller plays an off the wall 77' jazz for over 30 years, Killer tone. Its not a "HIGH END" axe. He can just play his butt off. (Lol!)

Thanks,
Coop'
Bass "4" Life . : )

I love Marcus Miller, and the killer tone you are describing is a Sadowsky pre-amp that Roger developed to Marcus' wishes.
 

Latest posts