• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Who makes a great J right now?

Your first-choice J-style bass would be:

  • Fender / Custom Shop

    Votes: 175 34.0%
  • Sadowsky

    Votes: 102 19.8%
  • Lakland

    Votes: 44 8.6%
  • Lull

    Votes: 27 5.3%
  • Other

    Votes: 166 32.3%

  • Total voters
    514
Quite right. Fetching around $1,400 on the used market, and seems to be masquerading these days as the American Original. Definitely on my list.
Well, do bear in mind that the Fender (Vintage-In-Name-Only) Original's neck-spec's are much more modern. If you want a vintage-style neck, just like the Sires are built with, go for the Fender Vintage '75.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PindyMX
I own MIA, MIM and CIJ Fender Jazzes, and love them all.

That being said, last week, I played an Allen Eden Disciple and was quite impressed with it. I haven't had the opportunity to play any of the Sire Marcus Miller V7 models, but imagine the Allen Eden to be comparable with the Sire brand. Further proof, I suppose, that one needn't spend $1K+ these days in order to get a "great" J.
 
Assuming you're not jumping into the 2K + category, and you have a Galub Skyline, I may recommend you consider the older JO or DJ Skylines. Great basses. Near 1K or less. Over 2K your choices grow exponentially. A quick search for "skyline" in our classifieds picked up a bunch.

To me, all the 2K+ basses are equally killer, yet I dont prefer the too smooth sound of the Sadowsky. Yet, that's to my ear, not yours, so.....enjoy the fruits of the MOST copied bass in history, Leo's jazz bass. Many wonderful examples.
 
  • Like
Reactions: wmmj
Please, nobody should think I mean "the best," I simply mean, "whose J should I be trying out?".

Looking for a (potentially new) Jazz (could be Fender, could be someone else) in the following configuration:

Ash body
Maple neck
wider 70's pickup spacing
Not necessary, but active EQ could be nice.

My son owns the Sire Marcus Miller J (60's style) and I'm pretty amazed how great that bass plays and sounds, particularly for the $$. I'd be happy with one of those, but I'm looking for something with a higher level of craftsmanship that will age well.

How are Laklands in the post-Dan Lakin era? I have an older Skyline Glaub that's just the best.

Thanks for suggestions.
Which model Sire? V3, V7? They also have some more exotic with flame maple tops.
IMO, the preamp alone is worth it and being able to switch from active to passive.
 
FB_IMG_1519072563274.jpg


Alleva ;)
 
Please, nobody should think I mean "the best," I simply mean, "whose J should I be trying out?".

Looking for a (potentially new) Jazz (could be Fender, could be someone else) in the following configuration:

Ash body
Maple neck
wider 70's pickup spacing
Not necessary, but active EQ could be nice.

My son owns the Sire Marcus Miller J (60's style) and I'm pretty amazed how great that bass plays and sounds, particularly for the $$. I'd be happy with one of those, but I'm looking for something with a higher level of craftsmanship that will age well.

How are Laklands in the post-Dan Lakin era? I have an older Skyline Glaub that's just the best.

Thanks for suggestions.
Please, nobody should think I mean "the best," I simply mean, "whose J should I be trying out?".

Looking for a (potentially new) Jazz (could be Fender, could be someone else) in the following configuration:

Ash body

Maple neck
wider 70's pickup spacing
Not necessary, but active EQ could be nice.

My son owns the Sire Marcus Miller J (60's style) and I'm pretty amazed how great that bass plays and sounds, particularly for the $$. I'd be happy with one of those, but I'm looking for something with a higher level of craftsmanship that will age well.

How are Laklands in the post-Dan Lakin era? I have an older Skyline Glaub that's just the best.

Thanks for suggestions.
 
Please, nobody should think I mean "the best," I simply mean, "whose J should I be trying out?".

Looking for a (potentially new) Jazz (could be Fender, could be someone else) in the following configuration:

Ash body
Maple neck
wider 70's pickup spacing
Not necessary, but active EQ could be nice.

My son owns the Sire Marcus Miller J (60's style) and I'm pretty amazed how great that bass plays and sounds, particularly for the $$. I'd be happy with one of those, but I'm looking for something with a higher level of craftsmanship that will age well.

How are Laklands in the post-Dan Lakin era? I have an older Skyline Glaub that's just the best.

Thanks for suggestions.
Can’t go wrong with Sadowsky!!
 
Presently my go-to is a US made Fender Jazz Elite... I like the fact that it has active and passive tone... the strings run through the body at the bridge for max resonance and sustain... there is a lot of versatility in tone as well... and you can't beat the neck feel of a Fender Jazz. Take a good look at that instrument. Another would be the Fender P-J special... do not confuse that with the P bass with a P & J pickup setup. The PJ special has passive tone control but a very wide tonal range and a Jazz neck. Good Luck.



Please, nobody should think I mean "the best," I simply mean, "whose J should I be trying out?".

Looking for a (potentially new) Jazz (could be Fender, could be someone else) in the following configuration:

Ash body
Maple neck
wider 70's pickup spacing
Not necessary, but active EQ could be nice.

My son owns the Sire Marcus Miller J (60's style) and I'm pretty amazed how great that bass plays and sounds, particularly for the $$. I'd be happy with one of those, but I'm looking for something with a higher level of craftsmanship that will age well.

How are Laklands in the post-Dan Lakin era? I have an older Skyline Glaub that's just the best.

Thanks for suggestions.