• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Who's White?

Hey man, it's a valid argument; it's also the way I see it.

The reason I was concerned about this dude's argument, was that I sort of felt that he thought he was in some way superior to, say, Eastern Europeans, because he was Western European (dude was Irish).

The Irish only recently acquired their "whiteness", they weren't considered "white" when they first got to the US.
 
Review of “How the Irish Became White” « The End of Capitalism

The Irish in Ireland of the early-19th Century were a revolutionary people: impoverished, agrarian, and determined to break free of the grip of England’s tyranny. But once these same freedom-lovers emigrated to the United States, a peculiar thing happened: they were faced with a society based on racial segregation and industrial capitalism. Moreover, there began a large “Nativist” movement by wealthy Protestant Anglo-Saxons who tried to restrict immigration and subdue Irish/Catholic influence in the New World.

In order to overcome these barriers, the Irish made a strategic choice: escape the bottom-rung of poverty and be accepted into mainstream US society by aggressively aligning themselves with the Democratic Party and doing everything they could to keep African Americans in slavery or otherwise out of the labor market. Thus they earned the right to be considered “White” and receive the benefits and privileges associated with that social category.
 
Kwesi - hasn't it, though? I know that I tend to refer to Oriental folks as just Asian when I'm not sure what country they're from. I also just tend to refer to Native Americans as Natives or Indians (depending on whether or not I know them, and whether or not they care), when I don't know what tribe they're from.

I would think that we do sort of use catch-all terms for this sort of thing.

Oh yeah, definitely, I was just talking about the color coding specifically, lol. It makes life simpler, methinks. I never saw it as particularly offensive or anything to be called black.