• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Why Jimi Hendrix is so Important

But I didn't say "worlds' greatest <insert instrument here>," and that's where people are getting confused.

I said, "Jimi Hendrix is the greatest rock guitarist of all time." I used the word "rock" in there, so Jazz, Country and other forms are not included. I used the word "greatest," and not "best," for a reason.

In the way I used the word "greatest," it cannot be disputed.

great
/greɪt/
adjective, great·er, great·est.
1. unusually or comparatively large in size or dimensions: A great fire destroyed nearly half the city.
2. large in number; numerous: Great hordes of tourists descend on Europe each summer.
3. unusual or considerable in degree, power, intensity, etc.: great pain.
4. wonderful; first-rate; very good: We had a great time. That's great!
5. being such in an extreme or notable degree: great friends; a great talker.

greatest (ˈɡreɪtɪst)
adj
1. the superlative of Link Removed
n
2. slang the greatest an exceptional person

I mean the rock guitarist who did the most to further the instrument's use. I mean the rock guitarist who had the greatest effect on the form. I mean the rock guitarist most frequently cited by other great guitarists as having the most influence. I mean the rock guitarist who played in a manner combining technical skill, (he did have it,) raw emotion, (one of the best ever,) technical innovation, and fitting the composition.

There has never been, nor will there ever be, a player who comes close.
1. GreatEST indicates no others are as great. Again, for artists, it is subjective. Is Renior greater than Picasso?
2. Hendrix did have an effect of the form, raw emotion, and he did play in context (fitting the composition.) If you mean by technical innovation, his use of feedback and effects, I have to agree. He gave us effects beyond reverb, echo, and vibrato. I don't mean to detract from anything he did. We was a great innovator, but not the only one of great import. I can think of Aldoph Rickenbacker, Les Paul and Leo Fender for starters. I know it isn't popular with the younger crowd, but The Beatles saved pop music going in a whole different direction. It was predicted that Dixieland Jazz would make a comback as the new pop music.
So he is an innovator among innovators. Certainly a great one by any measure. So if you want to define greatest as a slang term meaning really extra great, okay.
and All Along the Watchtower is one of my all time favorite tunes.
 
Page was asked in a 1975 Rolling Stone interview if he had any favorite guitarists. Here's his answer:
PAGE: Well, let’s see, we’ve lost the best guitarist any of us ever had and that was Hendrix.
You know guys....this is what makes internet forums suck. Arguing over crap like this.

Music is inherently subjective.

I like Jimi, some people don't.

Maybe do something constructive with the rest of your day.

I disagree. 2,000 views of people thinking about what is or isn't important about Jimi Hendrix feels like a "win" to me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tom Bomb
I think raw energy is a great description of Hendrix. It may be too raw and upfront for most to digest.

I would have loved to see a Hendrix and Steve Winwood group..

Also, Mitch Mitchell is in my top 3 drummers.

Or this little combo:

telegram_2559083b.jpg


Jimi Hendrix, Miles Davis, Tony Williams, Paul McCartney.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bluesdogblues
Jimi Hendrix is the greatest rock guitarist of all time.

People often dispute that statement. This guitarist has more technical skill. That guitarist is faster. On and on it goes. It's not a worthy argument. What does "greatest" mean? It certainly means something, but it can be difficult to define.

The Jimi Hendrix Experience was jamming in London in 1966. When you look at the sound, style, and innovation of that band, you can see how far ahead they were from everything that had happened so far, and it would take some time for the rest of the world to catch up to them. But that's not why Jimi Hendrix is so important.

The Jimi Hendrix Experience is difficult to define. They played psychedelic rock. They played blues. They played hard rock. What few people seem to recognize is that they were a progressive band. You won't find them on any list of progressive bands, however they incorporated all the elements. Extended song times. Experimental time signatures. Lyrics that went beyond normal boy meets girl; psychedelic or party themes. Experimental song structures. There is no question that the Jimi Hendrix Experience meets many of the criteria for a progressive band, but they can't be defined as a progressive band, just as they can't be defined as a hard rock band, a blues band, a pop band, or a psychedelic band. They were their own, unique thing, with a unique sound that had never been heard before. But that's not why Jimi Hendrix is so important.

Jimi was an unusual character. Painfully shy in many ways, but a player with women. Bold and confident on stage, but almost aggressively insecure. He was the last guy to think he was the greatest guitar player, or singer, or songwriter, or anything else. But it wasn't a false humility; nor was it born only out of insecurity. He had an almost pathological need to stay hungry, because he always wanted to be better. He played and practiced almost constantly, even after becoming a big star. He was afraid of becoming fat and complacent, and although he was proud of work he did, he was equally sure it just wasn't good enough, because he could do more.

As a lyricist, he was brilliant. It's easy to poke fun at his more naive, psychedelic, trippy or even sometimes silly lyrics, but if you examine the entire body of his work, he wrote a lot of lyrics of quality, introspection, soulfulness and honesty.

Jimi captured my imagination many years after he had died. I was a young teenager, who had discovered rock music, and it was taking me out of my shell, and teaching me things I would carry with me the rest of my life. Jimi was important because of the way he influenced millions, and reached deep into our souls, and gave us something unique that asked us to be more. You have to remember, I grew up in the era of stadium rock, when the idea of the counterculture, of opening minds, and trying to make a difference had given way to nihilism, navel-gazing, and just plain shallow partying.

Jimi recorded music from 1967 until 1970. He had only three years to assemble a body of work that is simply astounding. He played a lot of different styles, making each his own. He was always looking for something more.

He wasn't simply the greatest rock guitarist of all time. He was the greatest rock guitarist off all time by such a large measure that you can take the next ten guys on the list, and they still don't add up to more than a fraction of what he was; what he meant; what he left.

NOT ONE SINGLE ROCK GUITAR PLAYER has come up since him that hasn't delved into his songbook, and bag of tricks. That's the biggest deal. And he was never "the guitar player" in a band. He was the singer, lyricist, songwriter, visionary, and leader, and the only lead singer in the history of famous rock stars who actually wanted his vocal LESS prominent in the mix.

Jimi Hendrix is important because not only did he change rock music forever; his life actually had an effect on society, and mostly for the better. If he influenced people to abuse drugs, then that is the downside, but he hardly could've done that on his own. The positive things he brought about, in regards to performance, songwriting, electronic effects, depth in looking at styles and social consciousness easily outweigh the negatives.

Jimi Hendrix is the greatest rock guitarist of all time.

Nobody else even comes close.

I didn't know Hendrix was a bass player.
 
You know guys....this is what makes internet forums suck. Arguing over crap like this.

Music is inherently subjective.

I like Jimi, some people don't.

Maybe do something constructive with the rest of your day.

Hey it's just a form of entertainment. I personally do not care if someone likes or dislikes Hendrix, Gibbons, or whomever. What makes me enjoy this is seeing the cable from Jimi and Miles to Paul M. How cool is that? I never would have seen that if it weren't for this thread. Hendrix made a difference in my music life as well as is part of my life soundtrack from 1993-1995.

The guy who would rather have a screw driver jammed in his ear and would rather listen to nickelback.. That's amusing :). What might be amusing to him is that 90% of the music I listen to now was made in the 70's!!! I can't get enough..still discovering stuff. And I'm only 39.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bluesdogblues
Of course Hendrix is important. Not getting that is like getting why Bach is important or why the Beatles are important. He's HENDRIX.

But I think the term"the greatest" is a little naive. Music is too dense,varied, nuanced and complex to assume anyone is better than everyone else.

As for Hendrix's compositions, the first album is his best. The second is almost as good.The third is spotty. And after that it's hit or miss. I might go as far to say he was growing as a guitarist but his writing had lost some inspiration.

But also like Bach and the Beatles...music would not only not be what it is without them. And it's fair to say that anyone that you might like -- likes those guys.
 
Well he did get booed off stage when he opened for the Monkees. I think we could all agree on that event making him a total bada**. I would love to open for some poppy band and get booed off stage lol

Some of his songs I dig more than others, All Along the Watchtower is actually my favorite by him and the Experience. It's music for a certain mood and situation, which I think can be the same as how we view movies. Some movies you need to be in the right frame of mind to appreciate or enjoy fully. Some movies can suck you in regardless, while others may need a little coaxing to see them for what the artist/director intended. If I tossed in a James Taylor song in between Black Sabbath and Iron Maiden, it's probably not going to gel too well and come off right. One of my favorite guitarists is Roger McGuinn, and I'd argue that you'd need to be in the right mood or vibe to listen to his work in The Byrds and really enjoy it.
 
Page was asked in a 1975 Rolling Stone interview if he had any favorite guitarists. Here's his answer:
PAGE: Well, let’s see, we’ve lost the best guitarist any of us ever had and that was Hendrix.
I disagree. 2,000 views of people thinking about what is or isn't important about Jimi Hendrix feels like a "win" to me.
Sorry bro, there's nothing to be won here, it's just the Internet. But I thought it was a great thread you started - and I like Jimi, he's definitely top 10 in my book, even higher if I consider the whole package. I think there is an age bracket where you find a lot of Jimi lovers, people who were in the more formative years of say 12-30 while he was alive. Jimi was an interesting guy, lot of people have a skewed vision of Jimi and what kind of music he was making. He was an interesting voice just as America was blasting out of Vietnam and the Civil Rights Movement. He apparently thought a lot about male-female interaction and special women. Quite the romantic balladeer, even if it was crushing, messed up romance. :)

Here's something I thought gets pretty up close to Jimi the man - not incredible guitar but nice as a full package. You really get to see his face in this video - enjoy. Some acoustic Jimi
 
More shameless Jimi love. Watch in the early seconds, how at a point he make an obvious pickup switch change - almost looks perturbed with that dang guitar. I am moved by his hands-on work with his axe and the instrument, instead of somebody trying to entertain me. Jimi was trying to tell a story, get to somewhere with his music. I think that is part of his
"special sauce" , he was a musician first, entertainer fairly second. He didn't interact with the audience to "wow" them, he was playing that guitar. People were there. Jimi was humble - he didn't appreciate that he was, James Marshall(born Johnny Allen) Hendricks. We should. R.I.P. Jimi.
 
Okay, I love Jimi. Have all his recordings, been covering him in bands since 1976, etc etc. But I would not call him "The greatest rock guitarist ever". Great? Sure. Greatest? Too subjective. Now, you ask who IS the greatest? I couldn't tell you - I lump him in with guys who were so innovative that they changed how folks played: Jeff Beck, Richie Blackmore, Eddie Van Halen, Jimmy Page, Steve Vai (not all of whom I enjoy, mind you) but the greatest? Me, I fire up the Jimi albums now and again but I find that I enjoy Jeff Beck more on guitar. See - subjective.
What is vexing: Jimi died so young. If he could have kept the drugs under control, who knows how much more music he would have made - or where it would have gone. Heck, Jimi died well before the whole guitar-hero/shredder thing came along - how would he have fit in to THAT nonsense? Imagine Jimi tapping - ICK!
 
Jimi Hendrix is the greatest rock guitarist of all time.

People often dispute that statement. This guitarist has more technical skill. That guitarist is faster. On and on it goes. It's not a worthy argument. What does "greatest" mean? It certainly means something, but it can be difficult to define.

The Jimi Hendrix Experience was jamming in London in 1966. When you look at the sound, style, and innovation of that band, you can see how far ahead they were from everything that had happened so far, and it would take some time for the rest of the world to catch up to them. But that's not why Jimi Hendrix is so important.

The Jimi Hendrix Experience is difficult to define. They played psychedelic rock. They played blues. They played hard rock. What few people seem to recognize is that they were a progressive band. You won't find them on any list of progressive bands, however they incorporated all the elements. Extended song times. Experimental time signatures. Lyrics that went beyond normal boy meets girl; psychedelic or party themes. Experimental song structures. There is no question that the Jimi Hendrix Experience meets many of the criteria for a progressive band, but they can't be defined as a progressive band, just as they can't be defined as a hard rock band, a blues band, a pop band, or a psychedelic band. They were their own, unique thing, with a unique sound that had never been heard before. But that's not why Jimi Hendrix is so important.

Jimi was an unusual character. Painfully shy in many ways, but a player with women. Bold and confident on stage, but almost aggressively insecure. He was the last guy to think he was the greatest guitar player, or singer, or songwriter, or anything else. But it wasn't a false humility; nor was it born only out of insecurity. He had an almost pathological need to stay hungry, because he always wanted to be better. He played and practiced almost constantly, even after becoming a big star. He was afraid of becoming fat and complacent, and although he was proud of work he did, he was equally sure it just wasn't good enough, because he could do more.

As a lyricist, he was brilliant. It's easy to poke fun at his more naive, psychedelic, trippy or even sometimes silly lyrics, but if you examine the entire body of his work, he wrote a lot of lyrics of quality, introspection, soulfulness and honesty.

Jimi captured my imagination many years after he had died. I was a young teenager, who had discovered rock music, and it was taking me out of my shell, and teaching me things I would carry with me the rest of my life. Jimi was important because of the way he influenced millions, and reached deep into our souls, and gave us something unique that asked us to be more. You have to remember, I grew up in the era of stadium rock, when the idea of the counterculture, of opening minds, and trying to make a difference had given way to nihilism, navel-gazing, and just plain shallow partying.

Jimi recorded music from 1967 until 1970. He had only three years to assemble a body of work that is simply astounding. He played a lot of different styles, making each his own. He was always looking for something more.

He wasn't simply the greatest rock guitarist of all time. He was the greatest rock guitarist off all time by such a large measure that you can take the next ten guys on the list, and they still don't add up to more than a fraction of what he was; what he meant; what he left.

NOT ONE SINGLE ROCK GUITAR PLAYER has come up since him that hasn't delved into his songbook, and bag of tricks. That's the biggest deal. And he was never "the guitar player" in a band. He was the singer, lyricist, songwriter, visionary, and leader, and the only lead singer in the history of famous rock stars who actually wanted his vocal LESS prominent in the mix.

Jimi Hendrix is important because not only did he change rock music forever; his life actually had an effect on society, and mostly for the better. If he influenced people to abuse drugs, then that is the downside, but he hardly could've done that on his own. The positive things he brought about, in regards to performance, songwriting, electronic effects, depth in looking at styles and social consciousness easily outweigh the negatives.

Jimi Hendrix is the greatest rock guitarist of all time.

Nobody else even comes close.

Well said. Both Jimi and Billy Cox have an influence on my playing.