• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

NBD (Fauxdera content)

Aug 20, 2011
3,586
2,979
35
New York City
Since I mentioned that I was getting one about a month ago, I have been asked repeatedly if it had arrived. Well, today is the day.

To give a little backstory, a few months ago, I posted in a thread about Chinese knock off instruments, especially knockoffs of Fodera and Elrick basses. Long story short, I ended up buying one to give it its day in court and to give it to the people at Fodera to inspect, document, and perhaps use as evidence in a lawsuit. It came today, so let's check it out.
WARNING: I WILL BE VERY CHARITABLE DURING THIS REVIEW. SOME OF YOU DON'T KNOW THE MEANING OF GRADING ON A CURVE. IF ME SAYING NICE THINGS ABOUT A KNOCKOFF BASS RUSTLES YOUR JIMMIES, YOU MAY WANT TO TUNE OUT NOW. IT IS A $350 BASS AND I WILL BE COMPARING IT TO OTHER BASSES IN ITS PRICE RANGE.
I'll start with the packaging. Considering it shipped from China in just the packaging (I didn't spring for the HSC), the packing job has to be perfect, and there I can say that they succeeded. It was shipped in a styrofoam shell that left no room for the bass to move in transit. My one complaint is that it was actually a bit difficult to unbox and doing so ended up getting styrofoam pellets all over my floor.

On to the bass. It is shockingly good. Especially considering what I paid for it. There is no plywood to be seen, just maple, ash, and spalted maple that may or may not be a veneer. At this price point, I don't really care. With all these woods, it is no lightweight, but it feels well balanced, and sits well on my lap. It is a full neck thru with a 3 piece maple neck. All three pieces are quartersawn which I was definitely not expecting at this price range.

The fretwork is good too. No sharp edges, and the fretwork seems to be pretty good. The inlays are probably painted on, but once again, for $400, who cares.

The machine heads seem to be your standard issue cheapo import tuners. They'll do the job, but if I were gigging this bass, I would probably change them out.

How does it play? Honestly, I am the worst person in the world to ask this question. Things that bother others (neck dents, high action, thick necks, mild neck bow) don't bother me. That said, I like how it plays. Plenty of access to the 24th fret and a solid B string.

More information as I gather it.

iiiGPei.jpg
 
i saw the other topic.. show us more detailed pictures as i am very curious with these!

wood work and playability seem fine judging what you are saying. the other stuff is replaceable. how are the electronics?

(note: i am shocked with the quartersawn neck as well)
 
Looking forward to getting to see the instrument in person. The finish looks nothing like ours, the Butterfly is an abomination, the shape of the headstock is wrong...oh, and, yes, the fact that they are blatantly ripping off our intellectual property, well that's just a minor detail, but I digress! Thanks very much for spearheading this. Please keep us posted.

J

Since I mentioned that I was getting one about a month ago, I have been asked repeatedly if it had arrived. Well, today is the day.

To give a little backstory, a few months ago, I posted in a thread about Chinese knock off instruments, especially knockoffs of Fodera and Elrick basses. Long story short, I ended up buying one to give it its day in court and to give it to the people at Fodera to inspect, document, and perhaps use as evidence in a lawsuit. It came today, so let's check it out.

I'll start with the packaging. Considering it shipped from China in just the packaging (I didn't spring for the HSC), the packing job has to be perfect, and there I can say that they succeeded. It was shipped in a styrofoam shell that left no room for the bass to move in transit. My one complaint is that it was actually a bit difficult to unbox and doing so ended up getting styrofoam pellets all over my floor.

On to the bass. It is shockingly good. Especially considering what I paid for it. There is no plywood to be seen, just maple, ash, and spalted maple that may or may not be a veneer. At this price point, I don't really care. With all these woods, it is no lightweight, but it feels well balanced, and sits well on my lap. It is a full neck thru with a 3 piece maple neck. All three pieces are quartersawn which I was definitely not expecting at this price range.

The fretwork is good too. No sharp edges, and the fretwork seems to be pretty good. The inlays are probably painted on, but once again, for $400, who cares.

The machine heads seem to be your standard issue cheapo import tuners. They'll do the job, but if I were gigging this bass, I would probably change them out.

How does it play? Honestly, I am the worst person in the world to ask this question. Things that bother others (neck dents, high action, thick necks, mild neck bow) don't bother me. That said, I like how it plays. Plenty of access to the 24th fret and a solid B string.

More information as I gather it.

iiiGPei.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: 47th Street
The electronics... Well, there is no other way of saying it, they are DOA. It's a shame. I would love to he how the Schmichael Schmope preamp sounds. Yes it has an actual preamp.

More pictures to come when I find my SD card or my phone gains some battery life. Whichever happens first.
 
Looking forward to getting to see the instrument in person. The finish looks nothing like ours, the Butterfly is an abomination, the shape of the headstock is wrong...oh, and, yes, the fact that they are blatantly ripping off our intellectual property, well that's just a minor detail, but I digress! Thanks very much for spearheading this. Please keep us posted.

J

So if it looks nothing like yours, how are they ripping off your intellectual property?
 
I doubt anyone is comparing this to a Fodera or assuming that it is a substitute good... but if I spent my life building a brand like Fodera and some crummy little shop in China started knocking off my instruments, I would be a little pissed too...

Looking forward to getting to see the instrument in person. The finish looks nothing like ours, the Butterfly is an abomination, the shape of the headstock is wrong...oh, and, yes, the fact that they are blatantly ripping off our intellectual property, well that's just a minor detail, but I digress! Thanks very much for spearheading this. Please keep us posted.

J
 
So if it looks nothing like yours, how are they ripping off your intellectual property?

So if I make an Acoustic amp (like you play) lookalike that has the same blue accents and looks the same to all but bass players in the know (but still obviously trying to rip off the brand) and make it overseas, you (as an Acoustic player) and Guitar Center (owner of the brand and associated IP) won't think this is wrong?

If you think it is fine for the Chinese Government to allow this type of behaviour and have small (and some big) companies unable to do anything about it, that's up to you.
 

Latest posts