• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Double Bass Metal Bow Hair?

Jan 26, 2009
686
9
Lilburn, GA
Disclosures
Ronald Sachs Violins
Has anyone ever rehaired a bow with metal hair? I have a customer that brought in a bow the other day that was broken but the hair was metal. He swears that it eliminates the "hiss" sound that the hair makes on the higher notes on a violin.

He wants me to put metal hair on his bows but I'm not sure where to get the hair. I reverse-engineered his bow and it seems that you'd just rehair it as you would with horse hair. Am I wrong?
 
Has anyone ever rehaired a bow with metal hair? I have a customer that brought in a bow the other day that was broken but the hair was metal. He swears that it eliminates the "hiss" sound that the hair makes on the higher notes on a violin.

He wants me to put metal hair on his bows but I'm not sure where to get the hair. I reverse-engineered his bow and it seems that you'd just rehair it as you would with horse hair. Am I wrong?

Wow, that post turned out completely different from what I was expecting based on the title:)

I was looking for some hardcore type of a bow for heavy metal music.

George
 
Interesting. My teacher, Homer Mensch, experimented with metal hair. The idea was that since bassists had switched to steel strings, perhaps horsehair was not optimal. He told me that he had had a normal bow prepared with some kind of metal wire ( I don't remember which) and played it on a stage with other bassists listening. The result was very positive for a few minutes, but the metal "hair" would not hold rosin for any duration. That was the end of the experiment.
 
Horse hair holds the rosin in decent quantities in the rough texture of the hair, yes? Wire would be smooth I assume, and therefore not so useful.

Yes, this is the case. The scales on the surface of the horsehair will hold the rosin. In the case of metal, I wonder if zinc plated copper might act the same after being played in a bit. The plated metal sheering off of the inner core creating a rough surface?

My customer insists that it holds rosin every bit as good as horsehair..
 
maybe the customer had something else in mind when he asked for "metal hair"

2004388396.jpg
 
Aluminum has an interesting property: spalling.

From Wikipedia: "...Spall are flakes of a material that are broken off a larger solid body and can be produced by a variety of mechanisms, including as a result of projectile impact, corrosion, weathering, cavitation, or excessive rolling pressure (as in a ball bearing)...."

I know that many alloys of aluminum, when under pressure, in contact with harder materials such as steel or harder alloys of Al, and as a result of contact motion under these circumstances, will exhibit spalling. This is usually referred to as a "defect" and must be accommodated in mechanical machine design.

Perhaps this may be considered a benefit in the design of a metal bow. Spalling may serve to hold rosin. A different rosin characteristic may be required. Empirical testing seems to be the quickest avenue to exploitation of this idea. I fear there are other difficulties.

One is the 'hair' aspect. Would any alloy of Al be of sufficient mechanical strength to last for any time in a diameter close to horsehair? I think maybe not but it has been a while since I have toyed with such design ideas.

Technique requires the 'bounce' and 'feel' provided by the physical characteristics of conventional bows (tension, for instance). Therefore, an hybrid mechanical 'alloy,' possibly with another metal such as steel or copper; or in composite (possibly, embedded) with(in) a suitable polymer might be investigated.

One thin, flat ribbon of Al alloy comes to mind, as proof of concept. Two, or several flat ribbons set at an angle would allow flexibility.

Other metals such as Cu, Zn, Sn, etc. may yield better results...

~
 
Somewhere I have the remains of a broken bow that was haired with metal hair. A customer gave it to me to reverse-engineer. When I get back to the shop after the holiday, I'll grab it and post pics. If I can find a source for the hair, I'll try one out.