• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

17 year old curfew

Why does a curfew prohibit a kid from having friends, relationships and girlfriends? It never did for me.

Not for you no. Again this isnt a black and white thing here. It's silly to see it this way. You mean to tell me you dont know of any asocial kids who spend all their time on their computers and have no friends or girlfriends? Hm...
 
the problem would be what is more important: kid's social life vs parents peace of mind?

Like I said earlier, if you believe your kid to be reasonable and have an adult sit down and talk to him, make him prove to you he's old enough to know where to draw the line, isnt the parents' peace of mind unreasonable when it comes to a 11pm curfew?? the kid's proven to you that he will be responsible, and friends are very important, whats a man without friends, relations, girlfriends?
It's not either or. There is a world outside of your experiences.

And you keep implying that I'm a hard curfew at 11:00 guy which I've clearly posted that I'm not. Let's be done.
 
You're paranoid. The probability of getting high/drunk in college is much higher than the probability of your maid selling you lsd or being influenced by some 25 yr old couch pothead... which most 16 yr old kids actually really dislike generally.

As for being influenced by 18yr old kids, its still ok because its high school. Sure you'll be influenced, but it wont be nearly as bad as it would be for college students. And btw, we're talking about a 17yr old age limit, not 16.

Am I? All of those things happened to me....in high school. The kids in my school had plenty of access to booze and drugs. I don't know about the high school kids in AZ, but I've met very few who "really dislike generally" booze and pot. Why are you more severely influenced in college, rather than high school? I'm sorry, but now you're just twisting reality in order to prove your point.
 
Not for you no. Again this isnt a black and white thing here. It's silly to see it this way. You mean to tell me you dont know of any asocial kids who spend all their time on their computers and have no friends or girlfriends? Hm...

None other than you. ;)

I did know some asocial kids, but none of them were asocial because they had a curfew. Actually, the two most poplar kids in my high school had pretty strict parents. Staying out late wasn't a prerequisite for coolness in my town, I guess.
 
None other than you. ;)

Wouldn't that make your day :D

I did know some asocial kids, but none of them were asocial because they had a curfew. Actually, the two most poplar kids in my high school had pretty strict parents. Staying out late wasn't a prerequisite for coolness in my town, I guess.

Its not a matter of coolness, its a matter of real friends. Popular kids? They have, in general, NO real friends. There's a clear distinction between friends and school buddies imo.
 
I have two daughters, 17 and 19. Neither have ever been a problem. We always took the attitude that we were raising adults, not children. Kids want responsibiloity and want to be trusted. Give it to them. Allow them to grow and learn how to act responsibly.

We have less of a curfew than an understanding that the last train home is at 00:30 am. Miss than and dad is not impressed with heading downtown. Also, kids can get into bars legally at 16 in Switzerland. They seem to handle it well and not get wasted, at least my kids didn't.

I think it's a bit different for girls in that personal safety is an issue and they're aware of that. We have succeeded in not having any battles. We treat the girls like adults and they respond accordingly. Both of them have flown across the Atlantic on their own since they were 15, dealing with connections at ugly airports like Heathrow.

Raise kids with respsct. Challenge them. Help them to become confident and responsible and you and you won't have any issues.
 
It's not either or. There is a world outside of your experiences.

And you keep implying that I'm a hard curfew at 11:00 guy which I've clearly posted that I'm not. Let's be done.

You know we've been arguing for like 3 pages on the topic of kid's social life vs parents peace of mind and suddenly you stop arguing about it and say its all about something else without telling me what that something else is? Kinda confusing...
 
I have two daughters, 17 and 19. Neither have ever been a problem. We always took the attitude that we were raising adults, not children. Kids want responsibiloity and want to be trusted. Give it to them. Allow them to grow and learn how to act responsibly.

We have less of a curfew than an understanding that the last train home is at 00:30 am. Miss than and dad is not impressed with heading downtown. Also, kids can get into bars legally at 16 in Switzerland. They seem to handle it well and not get wasted, at least my kids didn't.

I think it's a bit different for girls in that personal safety is an issue and they're aware of that. We have succeeded in not having any battles. We treat the girls like adults and they respond accordingly. Both of them have flown across the Atlantic on their own since they were 15, dealing with connections at ugly airports like Heathrow.

Raise kids with respsct. Challenge them. Help them to become confident and responsible and you and you won't have any issues.

There we go
 
Wouldn't that make your day :D



Its not a matter of coolness, its a matter of real friends. Popular kids? They have, in general, NO real friends. There's a clear distinction between friends and school buddies imo.

No, I couldn't care less. ;)

Again, your assumption is quite wrong. My group of friends, which included the two "cool kids" still talks quite frequently, even though we now all live in different time zones. One of my friends just came to visit last month with his wife and kid.

As Jim said, their IS a whole world outside of your limited experience.
 
You know we've been arguing for like 3 pages on the topic of kid's social life vs parents peace of mind and suddenly you stop arguing about it and say its all about something else without telling me what that something else is? Kinda confusing...
Kids can have a social life and still let their parents know when to expect them. And I would agree you appear confused. ;)

I'm seriously done.
 
No, I couldn't care less. ;)

Again, your assumption is quite wrong. My group of friends, which included the two "cool kids" still talks quite frequently, even though we now all live in different time zones. One of my friends just came to visit last month with his wife and kid.

As Jim said, their IS a whole world outside of your limited experience.

If you couldnt care less why did you mention it in the first place? :D

And one outside of yours, since you seem quite fond of referring to your own experience as a universal truth ;)
 
Kids can have a social life and still let their parents know when to expect them. And I would agree you appear confused. ;)

I'm seriously done.

Yes, they can, but again, that depends on the time of the curfew, and a time set at 11pm is IMHO quite harsh for the kid to establish strong social relations at an early age.
 
Even someone with limited experience can make general statements. Actually, it helps.

Are we debating semantics now? I've made my points. I'll quit for now, unless we resume with the topic at hand.

I guess it all depends on who has the limited experience then ;) You're 33 and havent seen a school in 10 years. I'm 21 and still IN school. relating to the topic at hand, which is about a guy who is 4 years younger than me, I'd say my experience relates best to his. :D
 
Really? I spent 4 years at college, and only a small handful of my fellow classmates "lost control." Quite frequent? Hardly. Plus, it still begs the question: why is it better for a kid to "lose control" at 16 or 17 that it is at 18 or older? Does that extra year of no rules and lax parenting somehow make a child more successful? If so, at what age should children be allowed to start making their own social decisions? How about 14?

Honestly... because of jail time.