• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

19mm EBMM 5 string: fact / fiction?

Dealers weren't going to risk their dealership agreements and they knew what was going on with the "experiment" too.
Which is why I said non-EBMM dealers. Maybe it is a feature which only appeals to the working class? Gibson could sell 100 Les Pauls with some new dumb feature in that time, why don’t bassists have the same disposable income?
 
Last edited:
Aaaaaaand we're back to this part of the circle of this thread, even though it's been explained in great detail that 'Mr. Ball' set the thing up to fail.
Of course, he wanted to show you that if you want to do it, come with the money, instead of responding, "2 weeks is a bit short, but we'll come up with the money, then follow up with you, deal?"..instead there was no real serious movement to get this done, and the whole excersize and discussion, like now is pointless....
 
I think what it boils down to is there are groups of people on internet forums that think that because they all want something that the whole world wants it. So what follows is thread after thread saying..."why doesn't EBMM offer this??? They are losing so much potential money!" Just check the forum archives and you will find them. But those people that claim the only thing keeping them from buying is that specific spec largely don't actually ever convert to real sales. If in fact this spec is a hot issue and so many people would be buying them if it was available then getting the requested amount of people in that amount of time should have been no issue.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mikeswals
As I have already posted, I sympathize with the frustration. In no way did I diminish that. My only points were that grinding on the frustration doesn’t solve anything, that there is equivalent frustration going the other direction spec-wise, but that there are business bases behind what otherwise becomes an emotionally charged decision.

That’s all. I’m NOT the bad guy. Yet, somehow, the target is on MY back now? That’s just completely inappropriate.

No targeting by me. And Sterling Ball was up front about his tooling costs. Geschaft ist Geschaft (umlauts omitted)
 
I searched and found the old post.

You did NOT have to pay for the full instrument up front. you only needed to put 1/2 down, and the remaining 1/2 when the basses were done.

Anyone that's ordered a Musicman knows its at least 3 month to 4 month wait for a normal production bass. The Dargies, we waited about a year to be built.
So for a 19mm to happen, time to build the tooling would have added more time than the normal 3-4. There was No reason that bass players who wanted this coudn't come up with that kind of cash: so $950-1000 down, and 950-1000 in 4-6 months.
 
There was No reason that bass players who wanted this coudn't come up with that kind of cash: so $950-1000 down, and 950-1000 in 4-6 months.

There was no real advertising for this, it was mainly word of mouth via the EBMM and TB forums. And again: the ONLY color choice was black: I mean seriously, what's up with that? Sorry, but that does NOT count as a serious attempt to sell 19mm fivers.

Instead of saying "Hey everyone, I'm already selling plenty of narrow fivers and don't believe a 19mm option would provide enough ROI", Sterling constructed an experiment designed to fail in order to prove his utterly preposterous claim that there was no real demand for wide five. That is complete fantasy. Perhaps narrow is more popular overall, but many, many manufacturers offer a 19mm option, and some only offer 19mm.
 
There was no real advertising for this, it was mainly word of mouth via the EBMM and TB forums. And again: the ONLY color choice was black: I mean seriously, what's up with that?

Says the guy pictured with a black and maple bass in his avatar! :D
(chuckle-chuckle! I'm just ribbing you!)

I get it on the color choice. But it was also explained back then, in order for the pilot to work, the run had to be made in one color to keep the costs of the pilot at minimum. He said if the model sold and would become a regular model, then the color choices would be expanded.
Obviously folks were mad at the only color choice, but was what it took for the pilot to get off the ground, and the collector in me looked at as you're actually getting a pre-production 'proto' model, and stuff like that always holds its value.

I was onboard back then and was willing to do it because I was buying every LE they were putting out those days.
 
Yeah, I remember that all going down. I agree it was an offer that was likely to fail as it was such a short time frame, no options (only black!) and not advertised.
There was no real advertising for this, it was mainly word of mouth via the EBMM and TB forums. And again: the ONLY color choice was black: I mean seriously, what's up with that? Sorry, but that does NOT count as a serious attempt to sell 19mm fivers.

Instead of saying "Hey everyone, I'm already selling plenty of narrow fivers and don't believe a 19mm option would provide enough ROI", Sterling constructed an experiment designed to fail in order to prove his utterly preposterous claim that there was no real demand for wide five. That is complete fantasy. Perhaps narrow is more popular overall, but many, many manufacturers offer a 19mm option, and some only offer 19mm.
Emphasis mine. This, IMO, is the main factor (and, if I'm not mistaken, only the two of you have brought it up in this thread): it is not that hard not to find a hundred potential buyers willing to pony up the monies at short notice, if you offer a Model T colour palette, prevent the dealer network from getting involved, and let hardly any word out!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Fuzzbass
I keep hearing about how the company ALMOST did one, on more than a couple occasions, under decades of popular demand. I've done enough fruitless digging to just post a thread about this and see if they ever followed through.

Their 4 strings are some of the most comfortable wood I've ever sported. If they could just duplicate that format in a 5, for the sake of my big dumb fingers...

Thoughts? Resources? Looks like this is a recurring theme and if somebody needs to be pestered to make it a production item I'm happy to lead whatever charge might prove fruitful or pyrrhic or whathaveyou...
It's a niche (read expensive) market, but there are some wide spaced 5s available. i.e. Warwick offer a broad neck (20mm spacing) option on their Customshop basses. https://shop.warwick.de/media/pdf/3...Warwick-20Bridge-20T-20B-3dm3UuAnq8FQ16nn.pdf
 
Hi,
try Mensinger (Public Peace). They built custom basses. I got a 24 fret 5-string with 19 mm string spacing for ~ 1600 €.
Basses
 

Attachments

  • Mensinger-Bass-Unique.jpg
    Mensinger-Bass-Unique.jpg
    225.2 KB · Views: 37