- I was trying to be diplomatic with the comment about wood selection making a difference, as I've seen on Talkbass that the discussion can be very polarizing.(as with pretty much any discussion on Talkbass.
lol) But I'm definitely in the "it does make a difference" camp.
I don't have any fancy audio testing tools other than my ears, but out of the basses I own, two in particular are about as close as it gets. Both are Kiesel Icons with soapbar humbuckers/active preamps, one is swamp ash and the other is alder. I've modded the alder one a bit along the way with different humbuckers and preamp which did change the sound a bit more, but both have distinctly different characters/sounds.
Yes, I picked up on the fact that you were trying not to ruffle any feathers.
Interesting that you mention that Cliff's basses have their own particular "Cliff" sound... I know it's probably difficult in words, but how would you characterize a "It's got a Cliff Bordwell sound?"
That's a great question! I'm not certain that I am able to properly express what it is that I hear in Cliff's basses that give them his identifying sound, but I suspect it has something to do with the way he constructs and attaches his necks to the bodies. The more I attempt to describe it, the more inadequate I feel my attempt is...but I know it when I hear it. Sorry for the lame answer on my part...