• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

'63 P-bass

If money were not an issue, would you?

  • Yes

  • No

  • Only if I made my living as a musician

  • I'd rather invest in a carrot farm

  • I'd fire the drummer to get the money


Results are only viewable after voting.
Ok - I guess my point is I wouldn’t pay that for the rare original finish, regardless of what it was - Is take my all original slab board Precision over that for half the cost. There’s a bunch of 63s on Reverb right now for roughly 1/3rd that cost in fact. No disrespect to anyone who would pay that for something so rare. I just wouldn’t, that’s all...
I believe we are on the same wavelength here, my friend...
 
View attachment 3377345

View attachment 3377346

View attachment 3377349

1963, Sherwood Green, apparently re-fretted by Mike Lull awhile back. Supposed to be quite the player.

However...

It's $33,000...$33,000! Same place has a '59 P-bass for $15,000, & a '58 P for $8,000 with an early factory re-finish.

Now I've played a '64 J-bass that was Fiesta (?) Red w/ a matching painted headstock, & was blown away by it's playability & tone. It had a $10,000 price tag on it, & it didn't take long to sell. Fair enough, & I know that the value of anything is what you can get for it.

This is mostly just a rant about the prices of vintage Fenders, & I don't want to knock anyone who's selling one or bought one. That's not my intention, but HOLY COW, I can't believe there's a big enough market to support prices like this...


...oh, & the Sherwood Green sure is nice looking...
No way!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Keger Jupit
I can't justify paying more than $3,000 for one bass guitar, no matter how fabulous and collectible it may be.

It is much easier for me to rationalise buying 11 bass guitars for $33,000 (over an extended period) than one.

Am I crazy? My family think so, but that's another kettle of fish.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Keger Jupit
Unless you're stealing, money is always an issue. (and then you have other issues far worse than the issue of having / not having money )

In sales like that, you have to be able to cover the trade-in.

If that is a rare color / finish, the person who wants it is likely to already have a vintage P bass.
The salesman can "give" that customer a huge trade-in value, and still get more for the green bass than they would for a sunburst one.
 
I clicked too soon, said I'd fire the drummer to get it but didn't realize it was 33,000.00. I wouldn't pay that much, I'd get a comparable beat sunburst P bass that played and sounded great for 1/5 of the price. I like green but hate green basses, that may have something to do with my opinion too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Spacewoman
Mrs. 1952 and I were talking about the recent $768 million lottery jackpot. Although I don't buy tickets, its still fun to dream. Having owned an 88 Jeep Grand Wagoneer, the coolest vehicle in the world, imho, I told her I'd sign right up to spend $100k+ to get one of the custom-built, completely perfected repro Wagoneers if money were no object. So, a Sherwood green 63 Precision, the bass equivalent of that GW in my mind? In a heartbeat, my friend!!!
 
Mrs. 1952 and I were talking about the recent $768 million lottery jackpot. Although I don't buy tickets, its still fun to dream. Having owned an 88 Jeep Grand Wagoneer, the coolest vehicle in the world, imho, I told her I'd sign right up to spend $100k+ to get one of the custom-built, completely perfected repro Wagoneers if money were no object. So, a Sherwood green 63 Precision, the bass equivalent of that GW in my mind? In a heartbeat, my friend!!!

Nope, sorry, I own the coolest vehicle in the world, a 1994 Buick Roadmaster Estate Wagon woody with stock Corvette 350 and dual exhaust, it's a hot rod station wagon and moves my SVT's with ease.:laugh:
 
  • Like
Reactions: dan1952
I prefer modern to vintage Fenders.
I also prefer an instrument that if damaged or stolen, I know I could replace and be made mostly whole.

I don’t know how the upright bass players that have centuries old instruments sleep at night with nearly priceless items. One can’t help but get attached to one’s main playing instruments, that’s why I prefer stuff I know I can replace and still enjoy using.
 
I love vintage P-basses! I've seen and played a lot of 'em, but never seen a Sherwood green in person. So, it's a pretty rare color and that bass is in nice shape. I don't really follow the market at all any more, so can't say what it's really "worth". The other stupid rare color in my opinion is seafoam green...only seen one of those.