• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

A good dog.

What is a "Good dog" to you?

  • A dog that doesn't bite, but it doesn't really matter if it knows commands.

    Votes: 17 28.8%
  • A dog that stays away from my food and I can pet.

    Votes: 19 32.2%
  • A dog that knows and obeys basic commands.

    Votes: 36 61.0%
  • A dog that doesn't poo and pee everywhere.

    Votes: 26 44.1%
  • It's a dog... Let it be a dog.

    Votes: 16 27.1%

  • Total voters
    59
No biting and housebroken are the most basic requirements for owning a dog, non-negotiables, so they shouldn't even be in the poll. Anyone who would let a dog bite and defile the house is sub-human.

Beyond that, training in basic commands are the right way to ensure you get the most enjoyment from your dog, and your dog has the happiest and healthiest domestic life possible. Dogs actually need structure. They are a very rule-based species. They love consistency and meeting expectations of the alpha (um, that's you, the owner).

You should be able to control your dog's behaviour in social settings, because, sooner or later, your dog will need that control. Staying in place, walking nicely on a leash, not putting things in its mouth without your approval, staying down off people, these are all things that make the dog's life healthier and safer, and lets you and the people around you enjoy the dog as well.
 
No biting and housebroken are the most basic requirements for owning a dog, non-negotiables, so they shouldn't even be in the poll. Anyone who would let a dog bite and defile the house is sub-human.

Beyond that, training in basic commands are the right way to ensure you get the most enjoyment from your dog, and your dog has the happiest and healthiest domestic life possible. Dogs actually need structure. They are a very rule-based species. They love consistency and meeting expectations of the alpha (um, that's you, the owner).

You should be able to control your dog's behaviour in social settings, because, sooner or later, your dog will need that control. Staying in place, walking nicely on a leash, not putting things in its mouth without your approval, staying down off people, these are all things that make the dog's life healthier and safer, and lets you and the people around you enjoy the dog as well.

Brava. I agree. ^_^ Unfortunately, where I live, people seem to let their dogs roam around offleash without beign supervised and don't care that some are in fact aggressive... and I can't even tell you how many people I've know around here that just lock a dog outside because they don't want to take the time to train it. It's unfortunate and upsetting to me.

And Maki, I didn't ignore you. Then I'd miss out on all of the fun. :D
 
Bad Dogs?
Link Removed

baddog.jpg



Bad dog, no cookie.


Au contraire, I would say that's a very good dog. In fact, I would be so proud of him if that was my dog. ;)
 
Brava. I agree. ^_^ Unfortunately, where I live, people seem to let their dogs roam around offleash without beign supervised and don't care that some are in fact aggressive... and I can't even tell you how many people I've know around here that just lock a dog outside because they don't want to take the time to train it. It's unfortunate and upsetting to me.

And Maki, I didn't ignore you. Then I'd miss out on all of the fun. :D

Fair enough. And likewise btw. ;)
 
He's beautiful. One of my new puppies actually looks kinda like him as far as markings and color.

+1. Yeah all the hilarity aside. That's one killer looking dog. I love that look he's giving the camera.

Word. I think we've all seen a similar look when a parental unit/grownup authority figure busted our young ace putting out a small fire or the like. Kinda *I don't even need you to admit it - I KNOW you were effin up in one way or another, and it will now stop*

FWIW, this pic made this thread worth reading, IMHO.

Thanks guys. He is the best dog in the world IMO. He never begs at all, he's obedient (too obedient sometimes), he loves kids, and the whole reason we got him was because his previous owner (my uncle, which, in turn, got him from a professional wrestler) had to get rid of him because he was going to kill his pit bull. Yeah, seriously though, he had 2 dogs and then his neighbor, the wrestler, moved to Vegas and gave him their 2 dogs, one was the border collie and the other was a rottweiler, both males. When he took the other 2 in, the pit bull usually ran the house and the rottweiler subitted instantly but Yzerman wouldn't put up the the pit bull's crap and they gave him to me before he killed the pit bull. Apparently they got into it previously that week and the pit bull got a really bad limp from it.
 
Brava. I agree. ^_^ Unfortunately, where I live, people seem to let their dogs roam around offleash without beign supervised and don't care that some are in fact aggressive... and I can't even tell you how many people I've know around here that just lock a dog outside because they don't want to take the time to train it. It's unfortunate and upsetting to me.

+1

People should have to pass a test before they buy a dog (and many other pets for that matter). You should be able to prove, at risk of penalties and loss of the animal, that you have the time, patience, and resources to take proper care of and domesticate the animal so that it doesn't become a nuisance to your household and those around you.