A Legend Falls: Feedback

[MiniMoNK_17]

Hey guys. My band recorded an album in September 2004. First studio experience, didn't record to click-tracks, etc. We play metal, athough the newer stuff (not yet recorded) is more progressive. Can I get some feedback on the quality of the songs?

Link Removed

If they don't stream off the site, then go here:
[Invalid or Expired Link Removed]

Thanks,

 

[Adam Barkley]

The first clip was pretty cool, the bass has a good tone. The singer needs a little work though and the "melodic" intro parts to all three songs are repititive and boring

Pretty typical metal to me. The singer sounds like he is trying to be Maynard

 

[Woodchuck]

Hey guys. My band recorded an album in September 2004.

So, you guys are into some crazy time travel thing, huh?

 

[Josh Ryan]

So, you guys are into some crazy time travel thing, huh?

Damn it Woodchuck you beat me to it.

I'll listen when I get home, work sucks for new music.

 

[Benjamin Strange]

Overall I thought it was ok except for the singer. He really breaks the band.

I thought it was a bit Opethy, and sounded a bit weak (probably due to the lame singer). The band is good, although it is a bit generic sounding. I can't comment on your bass playing, since I listened to these through tiny computer speakers (damn pure volume).

Keep writing - it can only get better from here.

 

[Josh Ryan]

I agree with Benny Strange, musically it's not bad, but the singer is really bad, ie. out of tune, weak voice. It does sound thin over all, but maybe that's a result of purevolume? Some of the guitar parts got repetetive and moer screamo than prog, not bad though. I think you and the drummer are on target though.

 

[bass_guy33]

Nice work as always Casti