• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Aggressive P/J pups

Nedmundo said:
I have a 2004 Precision with S-1 and DiMarzio Model P, and the switch still works fine with the DM. I think it's standard four conductor wiring that allows easy series/parallel switching.

And, in response to the initial request for suggestions about an aggressive P/J combination, I would go with DiMarzio. I have just the Model P, and it's very aggressive, with lots of cut. It's great for hard rock on its own, and adding a Model J certainly can't hurt. I wouldn't want this pickup if it were my only P bass, but I have a '94 MIJ P that nails the vintage tone, so this is a great complement for a punk/hard rock tone.

Some have complained about low output on the E string with the Model P (see Luknfur's awesome P pickup experiment). I thought this was a problem through one rig I used, but with my "mini" rig of GK 700RB-II and Neo112 at a gig last week, I had boatloads of punch from all strings. Not a problem at all.

"I wouldn't want this pickup if it were my only P bass, but I have a '94 MIJ P that nails the vintage tone, so this is a great complement for a punk/hard rock tone."

What brand pickups do you have in this guitar? Does it only have a P in it or does it also have another pickup in it?

thanks
 
joshwilson3 said:
"I wouldn't want this pickup if it were my only P bass, but I have a '94 MIJ P that nails the vintage tone, so this is a great complement for a punk/hard rock tone."

What brand pickups do you have in this guitar? Does it only have a P in it or does it also have another pickup in it?

thanks

My MIJ Foto Flame has the stock Fender P pickup only. These MIJ pickups are excellent, and I've seen them used for $20! The 2004 Am. Ser. P has the DiMarzio Model P only.
 
No, but I have a bass on the way to me (will be here tomorrow) with Bart 72M55C's on the way. I will compare those two. I tell ya, the Dimarzio is like have a P pickup on steroids! I just got rid of an American P and I can say without a doubt that the Dimarzio has substaintially more bite and growl over a stock P pickup. I love the tone on this pickup. I let you know how it fairs against the Barts over the weekend.