• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Aguilar GS vs SL

I’ve done a LOT of reading on the GS112 x 2. A LOT! From what I have read, mixed with my own experience, There is no better bang in a 12 box of this form factor. Go ahead and weigh the pros and cons- trade offs. It is small, transportable, reasonably light, rugged, handles lots of power, hits low B EXCELLENT!, has great dispersion, front ported (my fave).

But...have you actually gigged with it? I agree it is a nice cab. But I would not call it excellent by any means. Too scooped. The public and Aguilar agree. It is discontinued in favor of the more mid focused DB series.

42 lbs. Is not reasonably light...to me. That is a pretty heavy box and an extremely awkward carry. The HDN 112 is so much easier to carry.
 
Of course I gig with them. I’m 65 and carry one in each hand for a load in. They are NOT heavy.
E826F1CC-F61C-4D66-95AD-17FBACE3EFCA.jpeg
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jefenator
No I’m not trolling. I forgot the weight. It’s spec is 42 but I’m guessing that’s shipping weight. In the spring, I’ll actually weigh it myself. They only have 1 handle and manages very well. The only time I’ll 2 hand carry is when I lug them up my 3 flights of stairs at home. As to the OP, I’m merely trying to save him 2K! I truly believe that the cost does not outweigh benefits as he already said he owns and likes the GS112 x2.
 
Just curious, what were the other Rigs you tried, but didn't stick with before settling on AG?
T$

The first thing I bought was a cheap GK Backline amp and GK Goldline 210 cab.These sounded terrible and the Rumble combo sounded better and was lighter. Next I bought a GK 700rb-ii and GK Neo 410 cab. Sounded good, but WAY bigger, bulkier and heavier than the Rumble 500. I ended up deciding that it did sound better than the Rumble, just not enough better to justify the bulk, weight, and cost. The third one I bought was the best sounding, an SVT 7 pro and Ampeg Pro Neo 410 cab. But moving it around sucked and I had read a bunch about the reliability of the SVT 7 Pro that gave me some hesitation. The Tone Hammer 500 and SL112s seemed to check all of the boxes that I was after. Other than sounding really good, I appreciate that everything is light and I like being able to take one cab for a small rig or both when the need arises. I also find that a TH500 and single SL112 makes a great low and medium volume home practice rig, while a big 410 not so much.

FWIW I did also consider a Mesa Subway D800+ and two of the Mesa Subway cabs, but I was able to get a better deal on the Aguilar stuff. No regrets so far, but I think I would be equally happy with the Mesa stuff.
 
When I bought my two GS112s more than 15 years ago, two 40 lb cabinets seemed very light compared to the two 60 lb Eden 2x10s that they replaced.

I’ve heard the GS112 described as the best small 15” cabinet on the market. I understand and agree with that statement.

If I were to buy another set of cabinets, I think they would be 12” Audiokenisis. I read a lengthy and very positive review of them written buy a guy who loved his GS112 cabinets. But realistically, my SL112s are good enough for my reduced amount of gigging these days. So if they don’t fall apart before I do, I think I’ll just stand pat.
 
I still have all four of my GS112s. I haven't gigged in a few years, so two of them see music room use only at the present. Years ago I wrote a thread "Desecrating the GS112", where, after one of the OEM speakers developing a rattle that drove me nuts (speaker is still very viable...I am guessing a small blob of something is under the dust cap...or something as there is no obvious signs of anything loose), I rolled the dice and put in the then relatively new Deltalite 2512 IIs...and REALLY liked them. Still have/use them, with the other two GS112s left as stock. I have watched as other "cabs of the day" came and went...I still was in love with my GS112s. They have bottom end for days. Yes, the horn can be somewhat harsh...but it's better than many out there (It may be the sam unit...it just, to me, sounds better), and I barely have it on anyway. I was coming from cabs that were universally described as mid-scooped (Peavey 410TX)...but I loved them as well, so the GS112s weren't really a gamble for me. They eye opener was putting the two cabs side by side and then realizing that the "little" GS112 went as deep, or deeper, than the 410TX and was every bit as loud with the same amp settings. The GS112 seemed to have just a touch more detail than the Peaveys...but it was SO much smaller and less than half the weight. At 68, I appreciate the difference! Over the years I have toyed with replacing them...but with what? Their value to me is more than what the market will bear and any difference that I might gain, simply doesn't seem to balance out with the cost of changing. If I were starting all over, I would most likely pick up some of the Genzler BA12-3 cabs and call it a day. I have their baby brothers, the BA10-2s and am amazed at how much depth and volume comes out of such a small, light cab.

In the end, I am still very satisfied with the GS112s and am glad that I didn't go for the DBs or SLs when they came out...no doubt they are fine cabinets, but the GS112s just have given me "that sound in my head" regardless of what amplifier I have used.
Kim
 
Maybe it's just me, but I used GS212 cabs. Two of them. I especially liked how they did not shy back when I used a bass with a B string and boosted the bass frequencies. But my guess is that the 8 ohm 212 cab has different speakers than the 8 ohm 112. However, I did not find that same boldness in the SL cabinets, which came, at that price level, as a bit of a disappointment to me.

I, too, was quite fond of the sound I got out of the GS cabs, but not so much fond of the fact that I had to lug around 150lbs of cabinet to a gig where I needed both of them.
My personal search for something that gave me similar output (or at least similar in the parts that matter to me) with less weight led me away from aguilar then.

In my neck of the woods, the SL112 is about as expensive as the barefaced Super Compact.
Which is about as loud as my GS 212 and weighs less than the SL112.
I flipped my GS cabs and bought a barefaced Super Compact and Super Midget. I lost more than 100lbs weight in my rig and have a smaller footprint, yet still sufficient power. Sufficient power in my book means that I can turn up the amp to a level where I can stand in front of my rig, play a G and loose the ability to see properly because the sheer force of bass my rig sends off make my eyeballs vibrate in their sockets. When at that level, I still have some headroom left, I consider my rig loud enough. The aggies were able to do that without breaking a sweat and the barefaced cabs do it, too.
My back is glad, because both barefaced cabs combined weigh in at less than 2/3 of one of the aguilars.
The bass is still massive. The aguilars had 4 12 inch cabs and 2 horns, whereas the barefaced cabs sport only half of that. In my book, the aguilar horn provides a magic sparkle top end that is something special. I do not care for such things too much and usually have only one of the horns switched on and dialed back so far it's barely audible. If you're into these things, the barefaced Big Baby is the way to go, it comes with a huge horn.
Apart from that, I always found the GS to be quite in the middle of the road. Sure there's that mid scoop. That can easily be fixed with a little mid hump on any of the EQs in the chain. Apart from that, they neither emphasize certain frequencies nor do they back off others (as long as we're talking bass guitar, that is).
The barefaced cabs are the same, minus the mid scoop.
 
i've been looking at a pair of 1-12"s cabs for electric gigs and i am curious as to how the MAS 112 would compare. similar priceand weight. high quality. anyone play a pair of MAS 112s to compare? sorry if this is too far of a derail.
 
Just curious, what were the other Rigs you tried, but didn't stick with before settling on AG?


T$

Previously, I have owned/played through a mid 70s Fender 15 Combo, Peavey TNT 150, Crate B100 combo, SWR working man 610/head and Fender Rumble head/GK 212 cab. I played through another guy's TH500 and GS112. After that, I had to have a TH500. The GS112s were acquired soon thereafter. As I have previously stated, I've used them for several years.

I have often advised others that if you're not sure of what to do, sometimes the best thing to do is nothing. So, for now at least, I'll keep enjoying the GS112s. If I get a chance to gig with a Neo 12 of some sort, I will certainly do so.
 
I also have been running a pair of GS112s for about 15 years and couldn’t be happier with them. Especially since I upgraded the drivers to eminence kappa 12As. 50% more handling goes a long way. Plus, I’ve found that when you can drive the cabs harder, they growl harder. I usually run them off of a GK 1001RB and get plenty of clarity out of them.
 
I’ve owned a GS 4x10 and two SL 1x12s, so certainly nothing close in form factor.

But to use those as examples, the GS cab was very modern sounding. More pronounced in the lows, some say scooped mids, and enough high end on tap for some sizzle and snap. The thing could really thump.

The SL cabs were VERY polite sounding. Even at higher volumes it was soft and unobtrusive. They were very musical and well rounded, but they did not work in my rock band as they didn’t thump the way I like.

Oddly enough, I also found them to be too light and to not have the smartest design (no casters or risers on the opposite side of the handle which meant you would also be setting the cab down on its Tolex). This might have changed over the years.
 
I’ve owned a GS 4x10 and two SL 1x12s, so certainly nothing close in form factor.

But to use those as examples, the GS cab was very modern sounding. More pronounced in the lows, some say scooped mids, and enough high end on tap for some sizzle and snap. The thing could really thump.

The SL cabs were VERY polite sounding. Even at higher volumes it was soft and unobtrusive. They were very musical and well rounded, but they did not work in my rock band as they didn’t thump the way I like.

Oddly enough, I also found them to be too light and to not have the smartest design (no casters or risers on the opposite side of the handle which meant you would also be setting the cab down on its Tolex). This might have changed over the years.
Opposite the handle (on the SL cab) i took out 1 screw from each metal corner, and added a rubber foot with the same screw and hole.