• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Alternative to Prosteels?

So I have an american p bass and I love it for that "piano" tone we all know and love.
I've been putting prosteels on it for a couple years but I just feel like there's something better.
I've grown to not like how they sound in the mix.

I'm looking for a string that has that growly, piano pick tone but not to dry and tingy like prosteels.
 
So I have an american p bass and I love it for that "piano" tone we all know and love.
I've been putting prosteels on it for a couple years but I just feel like there's something better.
I've grown to not like how they sound in the mix.

I'm looking for a string that has that growly, piano pick tone but not to dry and tingy like prosteels.
Have you tried the XLs? They sit in a mix better than SS IMO. More mids.
 
I'd say try D'Addario XLs, since it would be the closest thing possible to the pro steels, but in nickel. After that you should have a pretty good feel for whether you prefer steel or nickel, which will narrow your search by half.