I'm not sure I understand your statement. Isn't the Jaguar supposed to sound like a P if you turn off the J pickup?
And since it uses the exact same pickup of the VM P, I thought they would sound quite similar. The Jaguar and the amber P have different body wood, so they probably don't sound exactly the same, but the white P and the Jaguar should sound pretty similar...
Or are you saying you didn't like the playability of the Jaguar? I'm asking because I'm looking for a P tone with a Jazz neck and figured the Jaguar would be a good option for me...