Anthony Kiedis VS Billy Corgan

[ToadWarrior]

Billy's a better singer but I can't stand him.. I can stand Anthony for a little while.

 

[Corevalay]

If by 'raw' you mean 'awful', then agreed. He can't sing, he can't rap and he should stop attempting to do either for the sake of all living creatures with any degree of aural perception, sapient or otherwise. I'd say he shouldn't speak but that would just be mean. If you disagree, you are wrong, end of story.

I wish I was awful and selling millions of records.

 

[curbowkid]

Every RHCP live set I've seen, he just goes absolutely horrendous at times. The sour sound if you know what I mean

 

[Clark Dark]

I wish I was awful and selling millions of records.

word !!!!!!!!!!
anyway I like Nuno and Extreme a whole lot more than RHCP and the Pumpkins

 

[wraub]

I admit to being a RHCP fan from the first album on, although the editing and Autotune makes Californication unlistenable in a fairly complete way. That said, Anthony is definitely hit and miss, both live and in studio. Even off pitch on record, sometimes. I wonder if he thinks it's part of his style.

Ordinarily, I would crawl naked across broken glass covered in lukewarm monkey vomit to avoid Corgan's vocals. That said, SP have some decent tunes.


wraub

 

[sloasdaylight]

I admit to being a RHCP fan from the first album on, although the editing and Autotune makes Californication unlistenable in a fairly complete way. That said, Anthony is definitely hit and miss, both live and in studio. Even off pitch on record, sometimes. I wonder if he thinks it's part of his style.

Ordinarily, I would crawl naked across broken glass covered in lukewarm monkey vomit to avoid Corgan's vocals. That said, SP have some decent tunes.


wraub

Sigged so hard.

 

[wraub]

Sigged so hard.

They say you never forget your first.
I feel honored.

Thanks!

wraub

 

[bassinplace]

That's a tough call. They're both wretched to my ears. Guess I'd have to give the win to Corgan. At least he's got more angst/emotion/soul or whatever you want to call it in his delivery.

 

[Toolmybass]

in his delivery.

You mean studio right?....cause he is horrid live, way worse that AK

 

[bassinplace]

You mean studio right?....cause he is horrid live, way worse that AK

Yeah, I was thinking studio. Live, I don't even want to think about it. Awful.