• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Anyone playing bass clean with no effects?

Do you prefer the sound of your bass when playing live?

  • I prefer the natural sound of my bass and do not use effects.

    Votes: 343 84.1%
  • I prefer to use effects to change the way my bass sounds.

    Votes: 65 15.9%

  • Total voters
    408
Except in my solo set, where I use an octaver, chorus, and delay, I don't use pedals. I don't like distorted bass tones, and for the vast majority of my playing just prefer an unaffected tone, other than a bit of compression sometimes (built-in SpectraComp on my TC Electronic amps).
 
Never played with any for many many (read nearly 25 or 30 years) but over the last 5 years have been having fun experimenting with a few to add particular textures and sounds to particular songs. No of course, in reality, 80% of the time I'm still playing clean and un-effected with the pedals switched out of the signal chain between my tuner and the Sansamp VT Bass DI that I use as an amp/ speaker sim to feed FOH. Do I need them? No, but it can be fun to have them available for a change of mood or tone.

Here's my "before" gig rig...

A9E2C451-1BA6-434F-83C1-AE3C26988672.jpeg


And "after"...

585E0820-4FDD-4B9A-9A02-004A0C04B5D7.jpeg
 
If this was in the effects forum we'd all be banned for life. I can't believe how many bassists consider compression an effect rather than part of the overall EQ setup. That's like considering a graphic equalizer or a BBE an effect. The only pedals I use with the bass are an MXR flanger, an envelope filter, and a bass phaser. These are usually at home, gigs are just bass > compressor > preamp > amp. Split channel to the DI. Haven't tried the Ric-O-Sound live. Maybe someday.
 
I'm not sure if this counts as clean, but my amp has much more elaborate controls on it than the pedal I use (VT Bass). I go from bass to VT pedal to the back of my amp, bypassing all of its complicated controls. More than enough tonal options and EQ adjustments for me.
 
I tried various pedals early in my career but haven't used any at all in the past 20 years. I love the tone I get from my gear and don't need anything else. I suppose if you play a particular type of music and are trying for a particular sound, sure, if you need a pedal to achieve that, by all means use one, or two. Maybe I'm just a purist, old school bassist. If you love what you are hearing from your gear...and it can be accomplished without pedals...keep it simple. I own 3 awesome basses and have great amps and cabs. They do the job quite well for me as is.
 
Depends.

In one outfit, I need a vintage overdrive for certain songs to sound the best they can, and in another, a modern overdrive + a slight bit of detuned thickness + a distinct compressor effect + octave down + fuzz + analog delay oscillation effects + a looper pedal + possibly a phaser & glitch texture effect. I like preamp tone control in both.

Most one-off gigs, though, I've shown up with a bass and an amp. The simplest tools to get a good sound and good job done.
 
  • Like
Reactions: wmmj
whatever I use is always on for the full set, so it's more of a tone shaping thing than an effect. I generally play through a DI with no amp, so pedals just give me a little control.

With my G&L L-2000/L-1000, I'll use a comp with very low compression, just to smooth things out a little. With my passive P or J basses, I'll use a Beta with the drive so low that it only breaks up if I'm really plucking hard. Everything goes into a parametric EQ pedal to fine tune things and then into DI. Oh, and there's a tuner in the mix, too.

I've had fuzz, chorus, flanger, envelope filters... never found much use for them other than mild amusement at home. Maybe used the flanger on a song or two years ago, but everything has since moved on.