• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Anyone playing bass clean with no effects?

Do you prefer the sound of your bass when playing live?

  • I prefer the natural sound of my bass and do not use effects.

    Votes: 343 84.1%
  • I prefer to use effects to change the way my bass sounds.

    Votes: 65 15.9%

  • Total voters
    408
Never played with any for many many (read nearly 25 or 30 years) but over the last 5 years have been having fun experimenting with a few to add particular textures and sounds to particular songs. No of course, in reality, 80% of the time I'm still playing clean and un-effected with the pedals switched out of the signal chain between my tuner and the Sansamp VT Bass DI that I use as an amp/ speaker sim to feed FOH. Do I need them? No, but it can be fun to have them available for a change of mood or tone.

Here's my "before" gig rig...

View attachment 3212077

And "after"...

View attachment 3212078

That red Wal Mk is killer!

I just use an overdrive these days. It's a modified MXR Micro Amp. It's very simple and is my favorite I've had.
 
Last gig I did was bass --> Tonelab SE --> FOH.

I used five or six patches that I had tweaked for different songs/basses mainly different EQ/AMPS/CABS, but also a little bit of chorus on one of them. I had set up a ZOOM recorder at the mixing station (a fair distance from the stage and half-way up a hill, this was a big outdoor show) and on listening back to the live mix, the bass sounded basically identical on every song. So all that tweaking accomplished was a little extra comfort for my monitor mix... :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: JKos and Spidey2112
I just saw Eric Smith playing his Mike Lull M5V into a TC Electronic Blacksmith head and a pair of TC Electronic 4x10's, supporting Lalah Hathaway.

As far as I could tell, both visually and sonically, his bass was running straight into the amp with nothing in between except a cable.

It sounded absolutely magnificent.

Of course it helps that he is a master player. But damn, it sounded SO good. Kind of makes me rethink the idea of using pedals at all.

Come to think of it, Marcus Miller, who played after him, didn't seem to be using any pedals either, except one tune where he added some overdrive.
 
Last edited:
I just love the sound of my bass with no effects at all. ( I haven't ever used them live but tried a couple in a shop and it wasn't that I didn't like the effect ( envelope filter ), I didn't like what they took out of my sound, whether on or off. But in reality I have no need for them.

I wonder if the desire to play clean through a clean bass rig is popular these days as most gigs I go to the bass player has one or more effects pedals in their board.

I don't have any axe to grind with anyone using effects, as where I've heard them being used they work bang on with the music.
I have over the years used a little bit of chorus but now am looking at putting together a "small" pedalboard with a Dunlop Bass Wah, Octave pedal (not sure what brand yet, have looked at a bunch), maybe an overdrive pedal (Fulltone or something similar), a chorus pedal, and possibly something like the Aguilar Filter Twin. That would be more than enough for what I do. Have been looking mostly at Aguilar, Electro Harmonix, and Boss pedals. Know there many other great brands but these seem to be affordable and have some great demos on YouTube and other videos.
 
I just love the sound of my bass with no effects at all. ( I haven't ever used them live but tried a couple in a shop and it wasn't that I didn't like the effect ( envelope filter ), I didn't like what they took out of my sound, whether on or off. But in reality I have no need for them.

I wonder if the desire to play clean through a clean bass rig is popular these days as most gigs I go to the bass player has one or more effects pedals in their board.

I don't have any axe to grind with anyone using effects, as where I've heard them being used they work bang on with the music.
The closest I come to using effects is a built in compressor on one amp (that I turn off unless I'm slapping and I don't really slap) and an adjustable one on my WTDI (DI with Eden preamp built-in). I use the WTDI when I have to play through a backline and I want the Eden sound I get out of my normal amp. So far, I've used that compressor on one song, twice.

Really like the sound of my Jazz Bass as-is.
 
Funny, I practice with the most sterile tone possible. Come gig time, it's mostly clean, but I am NOT afraid to use effects. Two overdrives, an envelope filter, and a compressor. I also use a Moog Sub Phatty for all sorts of synthy goodness. Effects used right make songs come alive. Used poorly, they detract horribly. It's kind of an all or nothing situation for bass, unfortunately. IMO, a lot of bass players who eschew effects just plain dont know how to use them or aren't in a situation where they'll enhance the sound. I also firmly believe that all great tones, effected or otherwise, start with a rock solid clean tone.