• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

anything a pick can do that fingers cant?

I am mostly a fingers player, but i do practice with a pick sometimes. I was wondering if there is anything a pick can do that fingers cant, other than tone. I mean, notes are notes, right?

i can think of sweeping, but only because i can't. i have seen people do it
 
I paly almost exclusively with my fingers except when my band covers Tool songs. I used to play Tool covers with my fingers only but have found the dynamics to be suffering without using a pick. Sure you can use your finger nails and try to pull off certain licks, but sometimes it just takes a pick to create that certain sound. I was very biased about playing finger style only, but now recently, the past year I have found that pick playing has made me a better and more rounded bassist. My advice to you is try and play both styles. I have excelled in fingerstyle playing, but I have rekindled my love for our instrument with using a pick when necessary. It actually is quite fun!:D
 
+1 to all of the above!
I got in trouble during marching band practice once cause while the director was explaining something to the percussion, I set one of my celluloids on fire which surprised quite a few people.
Plus I've seen to many pop-punk bassists who have to stop a song every time their bassist drops his pick. Unless you have leprosy, there's no reason your fingers shouldn't fall off!
 
Fingers-plucking is very good, but I really also like:
  • Picking
  • Pick w/palm mute
  • Thumb slap
  • String-pop

I'd palm-mute while plucking with thumb, but that hurts after a minute or two. Tap & false-harmonics are beyond me...
 
Picks have a tonal and pecussive quality that is difficult (not impossible) to get fingerstyle.

I think that both styles are useful for bassplayers to know.

Pickstyle/fingerstyle, it's all good. Never allow prejudice to limit your musicianship.