Durability as an installed unit is something the socket maker can't make reliable claims about, since they have no control over how their parts are installed. Personally I think I'd rather have a jack that pops out relatively easily rather than one that has the potential to maul the guitar badly. Though if I was the overlord of music electronics, I'd make everyone use a connection method that lowers the risk of either.But you'd also think that a jack that is rated for more operations would also be made with more robust materials, tighter engineering etc, and would be more rugged and stand up to the knocks a bit more. But yeah, barrel side-jacks of all types are notoriously unreliable.