Oh before someone pics up my bad punctuation, I was not meaning that the basses I listed following the Pedulla were THE ONES that are less expensive.. Moreso Ibanez Soundgear, ESP, ESP LTD etc.
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
I have to agree that to my ear a P Bass is far from the top of the growl list (to my ear at least) and a J bass is much closer if you are staying in the world of Fender (That's what Geddy Lee played on Moving Pictures contrary to the impression many of us had that the album was recorded with his trusty Old Ric, Listen to Farewell to Kings for some Ric Growl). I like the growl from my Pedulla ThunderBass with the Bartolini Soapbars and active preamp, I've heard plenty of less expensive basses similarly equipped which growl like Pit Bulls. Spector, Tobias, Zon, Higher end B.C. Rich etc.. It gets to a point where you realize there are so many choices, that you might want to specify what band or bass player has the kind of growl that you like the most.
I'm thinkin if I found a solid used Jazz bass with a straight neck, I could drop some Bartolini humbuckers in it without droppin 2-5k on a Warwick. What do you think?
Best regards,
Brooks
I'm thinkin if I found a solid used Jazz bass with a straight neck, I could drop some Bartolini humbuckers in it without droppin 2-5k on a Warwick. What do you think?
Best regards,
Brooks
P-Tone growl example:
‪BRUCE COCKBURN - If A Tree Falls‬‏ - YouTube
That is nothing like the clip that the OP posted.
Yes I know, but in my opinion, it does growl and it is a P.
For the OP's clip, I think a Stingray or Sterling would get you in that area. Or a Jazz with the rear pickup favoured a bit.
But it does show that the word "growl" has at least a couple different meanings to bassists. Not like the link, but still growly.