• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Basses known for growl

People like to shout Warwicks from high heaven when someone mentions growl but don't fall for it. Not to say that they don't growl but it's not as if every one you pick up will be able to pull it off. In fact the only one that I've ever played that did was a Streamer Stage II. Personally, I've owned a Thumb BO6 BN and a Streamer Jazzman 5 LTD, neither could do it. There are plenty of basses that could pull it off at a lower price point. A Fender Geddy Lee sig (mentioned before), Brubaker Brute, Ken Smith Burner, a Spector Euro 4LX, maybe a Spector ReBop, a Yamaha BBG5, a KSD604 or KSD704, a Ibanez SR506 (it hurts me to recommend that to anyone :P), the list goes on. All of those can be had for around or under $1000.

my 04 Proline Corvette does it, and does it just as well as my 83 Fender Jazz did.. although, with a different tone..

it's not to say that other brands/models do not get growl.. the easiest way would be to get a Fender Jazz with 70's pickup placement.. if you think about it, most everything is either inspired by a P, or a J.. my Warwick is basically a maple bodied J..
 
That's what Geddy Lee played on Moving Pictures contrary to the impression many of us had that the album was recorded with his trusty Old Ric, Listen to Farewell to Kings for some Ric Growl

Rics have great growl. Some of the best examples are the early Yes albums like "Close To The Edge". The Geddy Lee Jazz with Rotosounds through a VT bass pedal will give you a very Ric-like sound too. Both are good options. :D
 
EMG's seem to have the most growl. Find a bass that has them or change the pickups in your current bass.

I definitely agree. I have a 6 string fretless with a single active EMG in the bridge position. It is super growly. I would compare it to the Jaco growl but with a little more of a "woody" tone (if that makes any sense) because it has a HUGE neck that runs through the body. But every bass I have played with EMGs tends to have that certain growl.
 
Well, I guess to the OP, that JT song is not what I'd call growly.....it's got more of a rubbery....quack? almost nasaly sound. It almost sounds like a jazz or EB-3 with the bridge solo'd, tone rolled off and flats. Idk, but very bridge pickup-y.

PBass Growl? I will respectfully disagree. Every PBass I have owned or played has had a warm classic tone to them.
I'm also firmly in the camp that does not see (hear?) P basses as being growly by any means. Could anyone who thinks otherwise post some kind of clip to represent that tone?


P-basses bringing my definition of growl, which some may see more as chunk or.....something else:
‪Rush - Working Man‬‏ - YouTube
‪Rush-Before and After‬‏ - YouTube
‪The James Gang feat. Joe Walsh - Walk Away [1970]‬‏ - YouTube
Invalid Link Removed
Isolated My Generation:
‪My Generation (Live at Leeds) Isolated - Bass‬‏ - YouTube
‪Black Sabbath Evil Woman‬‏ - YouTube
‪Black Sabbath - Wicked World (subtitulado en español)‬‏ - YouTube
 
Ok, please don't hate on me for posting this song. This came through pandora for some reason, and THE BASS sound is SICK!

Invalid Link Removed


Again, don't listen to anything else. Although after listening to some other JT stuff, the bassist he has is pretty damn good. Gotta dig that growly tone though.


Best regards,


Brooks

Nothing wrong with the song( Well, not much of a song,but that's ok given the genre :) ). I think the bass is a bit thin tho and not as tight as it could be in terms of note placement, given they must have all that a studio can do at their disposal.
Fun nonetheless me thinks.
 
After reading through these posts and relistening to the JT clip, I'm 90% sure it was Nathan East. That Yamaha bass of his can give some serious growl if he wants (listen to Eric Clapton's One More Car One More Rider CD for a whole range of what this bass can do). But this song from it is my definition of growl...

‪Eric Clapton- She´s Gone (live)‬‏ - YouTube

This is a tone I've seriously been after for a while, but decided that I'm more of a passive guy, so I just went with a P with flats and went for a Jamerson tone. Anyone know how to get this tone with a passive (preferably Fender) please let me know. Thanks
 
Growl is in the setup. Its not exclusive to any 1 bass.

No, growl is inherent to the bass itself not it's setup. Roundwounds and pickups in the right spots will get you there, not tweaking your string action and truss rod.

Well, I guess to the OP, that JT song is not what I'd call growly.....it's got more of a rubbery....quack? almost nasaly sound. It almost sounds like a jazz or EB-3 with the bridge solo'd, tone rolled off and flats. Idk, but very bridge pickup-y.





P-basses bringing my definition of growl, which some may see more as chunk or.....something else:
‪Rush - Working Man‬‏ - YouTube
‪Rush-Before and After‬‏ - YouTube
‪The James Gang feat. Joe Walsh - Walk Away [1970]‬‏ - YouTube
Invalid Link Removed
Isolated My Generation:
‪My Generation (Live at Leeds) Isolated - Bass‬‏ - YouTube
‪Black Sabbath Evil Woman‬‏ - YouTube
‪Black Sabbath - Wicked World (subtitulado en español)‬‏ - YouTube

No.
 
I have to agree that to my ear a P Bass is far from the top of the growl list (to my ear at least) and a J bass is much closer if you are staying in the world of Fender (That's what Geddy Lee played on Moving Pictures contrary to the impression many of us had that the album was recorded with his trusty Old Ric, Listen to Farewell to Kings for some Ric Growl). I like the growl from my Pedulla ThunderBass with the Bartolini Soapbars and active preamp, I've heard plenty of less expensive basses similarly equipped which growl like Pit Bulls. Spector, Tobias, Zon, Higher end B.C. Rich etc.. It gets to a point where you realize there are so many choices, that you might want to specify what band or bass player has the kind of growl that you like the most.

Geddy played the Rick and the Jazz on Moving Pictures. I would say that Rick basses are known for their growl, among other things...
 
After reading through these posts and relistening to the JT clip, I'm 90% sure it was Nathan East. That Yamaha bass of his can give some serious growl if he wants (listen to Eric Clapton's One More Car One More Rider CD for a whole range of what this bass can do). But this song from it is my definition of growl...

‪Eric Clapton- She´s Gone (live)‬‏ - YouTube

This is a tone I've seriously been after for a while, but decided that I'm more of a passive guy, so I just went with a P with flats and went for a Jamerson tone. Anyone know how to get this tone with a passive (preferably Fender) please let me know. Thanks

+1. Nathan East is the bassist on this track and I'm sure he's playing his signature Yamaha BBNE2. I have a black BBNE2 and that Timberlake clip is one of many tones it nails for sure. That Yamaha (and the TRB 5PII) are veeery underrated basses.
 
Searched for that growl for years and finally found it in two basses:

Stingray 5 HH i eq allot of mid in


American Deluxe Fender Jazz V, I modded it with :

1.Two Bartolini classic series humbucking single coil size pickups

2. Audere 6 z mode pre amp

3 Hip shot A bridge Brass kind



I am in heaven with both of these bases
 
Geddy played the Rick and the Jazz on Moving Pictures. I would say that Rick basses are known for their growl, among other things...

Noted about The Rick and the J Bass both, I have a Rick and it has wonderful growl. I guess I was doing poor job of conveying that for years I thought Geddy's whole classic growly tone must've been attributable to the Rick that I always saw him pictured with. Only later did I discover that at least some of that was coming from a Jazz. I Love Chris Squire's Rick tone on Yes's songs "Heart of the sunrise" and "Roundabout"; as well as Geddy's on Cygnus X-1 from Farewell to Kings and on so much of Hemispheres & Permanent Waves. In the "among other things" category on the Ricks, there's that beautiful rich singing tone in the upper registers which sings oh so nice too. :p