• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Beatle Basses

Thanks for all the feedback. The Hofner Icon sounds great, but I'm not sure if I can adjust to the tiny neck. It also costs a bit more than the clones. From what I hear the Rogue's neck is a bit beefier.

It is.


The Rogue also has a very different construction compared to the Icon, different pickups and a very different tone.

It took me about 15 seconds get used to the size of the Icon neck when I first tried it.

BTW, I also use a Hofner Icon Club which is similar to the icon violin but with a different body shape.
 
Flats are definitely the key for a classic sound. I'm happy with my Rogue with Labella Deep Talkin' flats (light scale) and the price was right. I find the neck comfortble, and the fit and finish are excellent.

P1010305.jpg
 
I can tell you the Brice from Rondo is a quality instrument, I have one for shows we fly to, so baggage handlers don't get to throw the Hofner around. Here's mine:
leftyfam07008.jpg

But this is my favorite "Beatle" bass:
eggricbyardlg.jpg
 
We have 3 Icons in the house now but non Hofner I have owned that seemed decent were Jay Turser and one made by a company called stadium,I owned a Epi Viola and price wise it was about the same as a Icon,you can maybe geta used Icon near 200 bucks if you look,what I did to mine was take the plastic tuners and switch them out for steel,Now the Epi the Turser and stadium all came stock with normal beefy type tuners like on real bass guitars.I remover pickguards changed tuners got straplocks and changed knobs and also went to flats from round wounds.I saved everything stock and put away now these bass's are much more functional for me.Our Icons are green black cherry and pink but just shop you can find one