Beginner - Unusual habit in my muting technique.

[dangevans]

Sorry, but I think is bad advice, especially for a beginner. A technique that sounds good and feels comfortable now might turn out to be bad for you in the long run either by hindering your ability to advance beyond a certain level (which I think is likely the case here) or by causing injury over time (probably not the case here). Now is the time for OP to get his technique in order so he doesn't develop bad habits that will be hard to unlearn later on.

To be clear, I'm not saying that there is only one proper or "good" technique, but there are definitely bad ones.

I teach tons of players every day, and no, if it looks like it will hinder playing/lead to injuries, sure- stop doing it. But what this guy is talking about is totally fine. I suppose you jump all over people for using a pick too?
Again, if it sounds good (meaning the technique makes you sound great) and FEELS GOOD (meaning doesn't hurt), do it!

 

[Lobster11]

I teach tons of players every day, and no, if it looks like it will hinder playing/lead to injuries, sure- stop doing it. But what this guy is talking about is totally fine. I suppose you jump all over people for using a pick too?
Again, if it sounds good (meaning the technique makes you sound great) and FEELS GOOD (meaning doesn't hurt), do it!

Geez, calm down. I didn't "jump all over" anyone; I just politely disagreed -- I even apologized for doing so! -- and explained why. And evidently you basically agree with my main point. I think we only disagree on whether the particular technique OP is using will eventually hinder future progress, and I'll admit I'm not sure about this because I don't entirely understand what he's doing. (How do you get your thumb "under" the strings to mute them?) Also, I think we disagree about whether something has to hurt to know it's wrong. Obviously it's bad if it hurts while you're doing it, but I think a lot of things that don't hurt initially, as a beginner is starting out, could potentially cause injuries over the long term. An example is plucking or fretting with a severely bent wrist. That's why I'm skeptical about the advice that it's okay if it doesn't hurt.

And BTW, I'm all in favor of picks and use one about 50% of the time.

 

[tshapiro]

I personally use many techniques and finger /hand positions. And, my techniques evolve each year - at least they have for the last 30. The least of my concerns would be with any technique you are using as you learn. Your hands will find their way the more you play. Embrace what works for you each day.