What are y'alls thoughts on best Noise Gates/Filters for bass?
Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Best Noise Gate?
- Thread starter TomRobison
- Start date
I have one from Rowin, that works amazingly.
https://www.amazon.com/Rowin-Guitar-Killer-Suppressor-Effect/dp/B01IV0CX7S
As an Amazon Associate, TalkBass may receive commissions from qualifying purchases made via links on this site.
I have the ISP Decimator G-String II and MXR Smart Gate. Both work great for bass.
Last edited:
Consider one that has an external loop, such that the noise detector is pre-loop but the gate is post-loop. I have had great success with the Rocktron Guitar Silencer.
I'm running a rig similar to Royal Blood with a bass chain and a guitar chain. A noise gate on the guitar chain is an absolute must. I've tried the MXR Smart Gate and the Boss NS-2 to meh effect. I ended up with the Electro-Harmonix Silencer and I love it! I also tossed the NS-2 onto my bass chain just to knock down a little hum between songs and it does a good job of that.
- Jun 6, 2012
- 4,837
- 6,859
- Disclosures
- I don't wait 30 minutes after eating, to go swimming.
Honestly I've never heard of anyone using a noise gate for bass. My rig is very (totally) quiet.
I've never heard a noise gate in pedal format that I could stomach (though admittedly I stopped checking them out years ago for that reason, so I guess it's possible some very recent products are tolerable?)...the problem to my ear is that they all wind up calling attention to the noise that's present when you're playing! iow I think it's easier to get your brain to subconsciously ignore steady-state noise, but if that same noise disappears whenever you stop playing, you become more aware of its reappearance when you start playing again.
So if I needed a "noise eliminator" I wouldn't get a simple gate; instead I'd get something like the Behringer SNR-2000 that combines a very gentle downward expander (similar to a noise gate, but less steep/less quick action) with a dynamic sliding low-pass filter (so it's like slowly rolling off the hi treble with a tone control whenever -- but only when -- there's no material being played that has frequency content in that register).
So if I needed a "noise eliminator" I wouldn't get a simple gate; instead I'd get something like the Behringer SNR-2000 that combines a very gentle downward expander (similar to a noise gate, but less steep/less quick action) with a dynamic sliding low-pass filter (so it's like slowly rolling off the hi treble with a tone control whenever -- but only when -- there's no material being played that has frequency content in that register).
I have experience with the Noise Decimator II and it works like a charm.
My house is noisy and some of my basses have single coils, so I use an EHX Silencer, which has a loop.
The input comes from my tuner pedal and the output goes to the amp. Everything else is in the loop.
It's easy to dial in so that it's not "too quiet" when closed, and doesn't close so quickly as to be noticeable. It's easy enough to set that I don't get cranky when my kid comes over and messes with all the knobs.
The input comes from my tuner pedal and the output goes to the amp. Everything else is in the loop.
It's easy to dial in so that it's not "too quiet" when closed, and doesn't close so quickly as to be noticeable. It's easy enough to set that I don't get cranky when my kid comes over and messes with all the knobs.
Donner Noise Killer! Works great, has latching foot switch! There’s one in the classifieds $30! I have 2 of them!
I've always seen noise gates as a temporary solution that doesn't fix the core issue: noise in your signal chain that is most likely cuased by power and/or cables. Isolate the power supplies and change all cables.
