• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Birth Year Bass

Bar Band Bassman

Supporting Member
Aug 26, 2010
2,848
5,742
Land of Mary
For me, a birth year bass is a good news/bad news joke. Good news: there were only 2 choices. Bad news: a 1955 bass is going to be REALLY pricey! Like, $18K for a p-bass with original everything. Gibson's not-yet-called EB-1 but simply "Gibson Bass" may be considerably cheaper, but still crazy $, IF I could find one! '53, '54, '56, '58, yeah. '55? Nope. 🤷‍♂️

BBB
 
I was lucky to find a '51 body [$200.00] & '55 neck [$125.00], both my senior, back in 1989 [gotta love Leo's modular design] that unbeknownst to me, would become my forever bass.
IMG_1817.JPG


Back in those days days it was relatively easy to find some hidden gems, like this 1952 Tadeo Gomez made P bass [traded '58 P Bass, see below].
52 P bass.jpeg


And this 1956 P Bass [$600.00, refin bought unassembled].
56 P Bass_1024 2.jpg


But even before my backwards slide down to early slab obsession, it was a 1958 P Bass [$800.00] that opened my eyes to the glory of vintage. Those were the days, as they say.
58 P Bass _1024.jpg
 
Last edited:
I had plenty of chances to get a birth year bass for a reasonable price, but that was a long time ago.

Now I can probably get a birth year car cheaper than a birth year bass, but neither one are "cheap".

Several years ago I had a serious craving for a stack knob Jazz bass, (NOT a birth year) and now I have a really nice one, but I built it. Had I bought an original '61 or '62, I would have needed to take out a second mortgage on my house. I love basses and playing bass, but having an old Fender or any other old bass that's close to or more than $10k never made a lot of sense to me, especially when I could buy a really nice bass for around $1k.

I guess I just don't have much museum curator in me;)
 
+1 for a Custom Shop.

I get the charm and even the bragging rights of owning a bass that is the same age as you. But to pay the maximum amount of money for the oldest and most deteriorated instrument makes little to no sense.

I wasn't born in '69 but i once had a '69 P. it was in decent shape and sounded great. But when I went to gigs, I usually grabbed my custom shop p because I didn't want to mess up such an expensive and somewhat fragile bass. I eventually sold it and bought a couple of really nice new basses that actually got played.

Just my experience. I'm sure most will disagree.
 
Born Aug. 1951. BYB? Not likely! Nobody knows but it is assumed that less than 100 1951 P Basses were made with production starting in Oct. '51. If so, of that 100, how many are in exsistance today? Probably very, very few.

So, BYB? It ain't gonna happen for me. Couldn't afford one if there were any up for sell.

But..............I do own this (Feb. '53) and it is only one year and 3 months off from being a 1951 BYB. As good as it's gonna get for me. Bought if from Guitar Center in Denver and had it shipped to Columbus, Ohio. Bought it on the tail end of the 2008 economic mess here in the USA so it was price right for me.

GC Los Angeles had it listed for $16,000 and it sat in the store for over 5 years, no buyers. Then, GC LA reduced the price 50% and someone at the Denver GC bought it. Changed their mind and returned it.

My son accidently saw it on GC's website and told me about it. I bought it knowing I had 3 days for a full refund. GC Denver shipped it UPS Next Day Air (no extra charge), got it in less than 24 hrs. Loved it at first sight. 100% original except for the phenolic saddles. Included the original 1953 gig bag and yes, "they" had gig bags back then.

Has a ton of mileage and real deal relicing but is in excellent playability condition.

BYB? For me, a 1951 Boomer, this is as good as it'll get.

(Super loved 2saddleslab photos and bass stories!)
20240903_103945.jpg
 
Last edited: