R1 should be changed to 200k if it goes immediately after the pickup leads....wasn't sure if I was clear about that. 3M is too high to load down the pickups properly, and it will sound really bright if placed right after the pickup. 200k is reasonably close to a volume pot and tone control in parallel (from a loading perspective).
If you place this preamp after the volume and tone controls you should leave R1 high (1M+).
Ah, gotcha.
Yep, if you are going straight after the pickups with no volume pot to load them down, you need a lower resistance there to simulate that volume pot.
Even then, 200K is a bit low for my taste. I would have tried maybe a 400K.
