Guys,
As much as I like to bust Ken's chops (all in good fun tho of course), he really wasn't saying the tone was generally bad, or even worse, wrong for the musical setting. This really was just him kiddin' around with us about his general anti-P orientation.
Can't recall if it was in this thread, but he did a tropical gig where he played a supplied bass and yep, it was a P. I gave him endless crap about "converting" and stuff (which of course he deflected).
Anyway, don't read too much into his comment... it really was just kiddin' around and not meaning to seriously dis the P bass or its appropriate applications. P vs J is like Ford vs Chevy. You gotta' be able to throw some tongue-in-cheek jabs back and forth or it's just no fun anymore.
Why am I posting this? Because I figure Ken's already on the road and off TB until next week. He's headed out to a place for the weekend that I don't think he has internet access at, and I didn't want this to fester into more than it needed to be before he had a chance to reply (again).