• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Club Sadowsky!!!

IME the Dunlop screws are smaller than most others. So, when I do a replacement, I often have to go with the toothpick-and-Elmers-glue solution. The only caveat is not to use too much glue. Has always worked fine for me.

I haven't used the newer Schallers (and it's literally been decades since I used the originals), but I doubt that their screws are smaller than Dunlops. But if they are: toothpicks and glue!
I've had the opposite experience. The Dunlops are larger than existing every time I've installed them on different basses. :D But not a Sadowsky yet. C'mon Monday!
 
  • Like
Reactions: JoshS
IME the Dunlop screws are smaller than most others. So, when I do a replacement, I often have to go with the toothpick-and-Elmers-glue solution. The only caveat is not to use too much glue. Has always worked fine for me.

I haven't used the newer Schallers (and it's literally been decades since I used the originals), but I doubt that their screws are smaller than Dunlops. But if they are: toothpicks and glue!

T & G is the way to go. I recently replaced some Schaller for Dunlop on a friends Warwick - I had to do the toothpick & glue method. The Dunlop screws were definitely smaller.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JoshS
OK, now with a couple opposite experiences on the sizes, I might just leave it! :laugh: (Edit: Thanks for the input, btw) All of these have their own dedicated neotech megastrap anyway. Unfortunately, none with the Sadowsky logo.

My Metro (which I bought used in the classifieds here) had been changed to Schaller prior to arrival (which was a pleasant surprise), but the buttons are really pretty tight.
 
OK, now with a couple opposite experiences on the sizes, I might just leave it! :laugh: (Edit: Thanks for the input, btw) All of these have their own dedicated neotech megastrap anyway. Unfortunately, none with the Sadowsky logo.

My Metro (which I bought used in the classifieds here) had been changed to Schaller prior to arrival (which was a pleasant surprise), but the buttons are really pretty tight.
fuzzbass is mistaken, jmain is correct. sorry i missed this. yeah the dunlops screws are longer and thicker (TWSS!) so you'll probably need the extra wood to fill the hole and make it tight (TWSS!!).
 
fuzzbass is mistaken, jmain is correct.

I assume jmain and I both right, and maybe Dunlop is in the middle. Most of my basses have come with Dunlops installed, but on the exceptions, the Dunlop Dual Design screws were smaller than the screws from the unlocked buttons that they replaced. This was definitely true for my Benavente and Nordstrand basses which had big buttons and big screws. I thought it was also true when I replaced the old-school Schaller locks on my Fender RB5's with DDD's, but that was back in the early aughts and I'm not certain.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JoshS
I assume jmain and I both right, and maybe Dunlop is in the middle. Most of my basses have come with Dunlops installed, but on the exceptions, the Dunlop Dual Design screws were smaller than the screws from the unlocked buttons that they replaced. This was definitely true for my Benavente and Nordstrand basses which had big buttons and big screws. I thought it was also true when I replaced the old-school Schaller locks on my Fender RB5's with DDD's, but that was back in the early aughts and I'm not certain.
wow... I've literally probably replaced over 100 strap buttons of various types including non NYC Sadowsky with Dunlop singles and duals. The Dunlops have always been bigger. FWIW I guess.
 
You know things are good when the bass, preamp and amp are all set flat, and the FOH guy says he’s set flat too, and it sounds amazing!
6C3159FB-A218-471E-9D96-9E192FFA1F4B.jpeg
 
wow... I've literally probably replaced over 100 strap buttons of various types including non NYC Sadowsky with Dunlop singles and duals. The Dunlops have always been bigger. FWIW I guess.

Same. I have used Dunlop Dual Designs on virtually every bass I've had as far back as I can remember and, without exception, the Dunlop screws were always bigger than what they replaced.
 
This is very interesting, because last December Roger himself replied to me that "We are keeping the Super J and Super P as proprietary to the NYC Custom shop." (post -> Club Sadowsky!!!).
Thanks for the info.

UPDATE: I just received the update info from Germany Customshop, Super J is no longer available on German builds and like what Roger said, they are keeping the Super J and Super P as proprietary to the NYC Custom shop, I ordered my first one way before this decision made, so my German customshop bass with Super J is gonna be the first and the last one with Super J. Cheers.
 
Last edited:
why the HECK would you go from good to bad???

(jk total troll post, been discussed a bunch lol)

“Oh no you didn’t!!!” I like the new S Locks and put them on both my Sadowsky basses. Flame away! :smug:
 
Last edited:
“Oh no you didn’t!!!” I like the new S Locks and put them on both my Sadowsky basses. Flame away! :smug:

They are close to OEM on Rickenbacker (Ric using their own buttons), which is why I'm in so deep in on them. I couldn't say if they are as silent as advertised, since I don't use both parts, but they work well enough for me. :) I don't have the same experience with Dunlop, but I've started taking my 5-24 out rather than the 4003s/W.

Given that enough of you guys trust them, some of you guys which I trust, I'll hold off on the glue and toothpicks for now.
 
Given that enough of you guys trust them, some of you guys which I trust, I'll hold off on the glue and toothpicks for now.

In the decade-plus I used the original Schallers they were a constant struggle to maintain (don't get me started) and I had a number of near disasters. Once I tried the Dunlop Dual Designs... forget about it, they were perfect. Been using them exclusively for two decades and haven't had any issues, even with the ones I've used longest. Also, the Dunlops are reasonably secure with an unlocked strap, which is how I rehearse at home*.

The new Schallers eliminated the biggest design flaw with the originals, but aren't a radical enough redesign for me to consider them over DDD. That said, I totally understand wanting consistency across all basses because that means not having to think about which strap goes with which bass!



*Sadowsky content: this is my favorite strap for home rehearsal. The four holes at the end allow it to be used with all my basses, no ladder adjustment necessary. Most of my axes are Fender Shaped Objects, but I own two non-FSOs, including a single-cut.

PXL_20210227_174032762.jpg


It's also comfy as heck: supple and padded, and the suede underneath keeps it from being too slippery.
 

Latest posts