I think this has more to do with your love for Quantums than it does any particular issues comparativley with J style basses. That would also explain why you liked the PJ better than the JJ, IMHO. Much more "modern" sounding, and a whole different kind of presence.That was the bass I am talking about. It was an NYC SC JJ. I've only owned two Sadowskys. That one and the PJ-R that Rodney snagged a couple of weeks ago. The JJ had the "magic" formula, Ash/maple, but my ears didn't hear what the TB brethren describe. I said I would like to try another to see if it was the bass or the ears.

