• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Criminally commercially unsuccessful bands

The god machine

Two brilliant rock albums in the beginning of the 90'. They split up after the bass player died. Singer and guitarist Robin Proper Shepphard then formed Sophia.

Who remembers them ?

Scenes from the second storey


One last laugh in a place of dying
 
There are bands that I love, that are just never going to be commercially successful (I'm looking at you obscure instrumental prog & djent), but there are bands that I just don't get why they never made it big.

King's X
I've been reading the King's X Oral History book and pretty much all the musicians in the book, (which are really respected names), are equally confused as to why they never became huge arena filling headliners. Amazing talent, great songs, all that.

Who else should have made it big that didn't?
 
The Beta Band - they were innovative, original and I think they were fecking great, but they self-sabotaged their debut album, never sold records in great numbers and ended up £100,000 in debt to their record company before they split... their 3 E.P's still sounds fresh today...
Ouch. I remember them getting hyped in High Fidelity (a great movie, IMO).
 
  • Like
Reactions: MCF and MonetBass
There are bands that I love, that are just never going to be commercially successful (I'm looking at you obscure instrumental prog & djent), but there are bands that I just don't get why they never made it big.

King's X
I've been reading the King's X Oral History book and pretty much all the musicians in the book, (which are really respected names), are equally confused as to why they never became huge arena filling headliners. Amazing talent, great songs, all that.

Who else should have made it big that didn't?

Galactic Cowboys (another Houston band closely associated with King's X) and Alien Ant Farm.
 
I 'liked' the "my band" response, which I was going to say but - more objective - I also had a stringer job for a UK magazine which had a Liveology column for unsigned band reviews. I saw a lot of bands, and made a point of principle in buying their cassettes if they sold any. So many good live performances, backed up by a dozen or so songs recorded in 8-track or suchlike cheap studios. AFAIK, none of my little reviews gave them more than a small legup. No point in mentioning them all, unless somebody who used to be in either Manchester's The Deckchairs or London (prev Croatia)'s Stella Maris Googles themselves, 20 years later.

Lot of mentions for Gentle Giant but their predecessors Simon Dupree and the Big Sound had a hit with Kites but they hated it and look like they have form for not spreading their legs in the name of success.

Anyways, Doves and Elbow (partic the latter - post "Seldom Seen Kid") have had decent success this side of the pond, but why don't people ever go back to earlier albums? "Lost Souls" and "Asleep in the Back", respectively, are two of the greatest debut albums but with miserable YT views. Do yourself and them a favour:



And Prefab Sprout top my 80s criminally-undersuccessful list (TalkTalk running them close). I think Paddy McAloon tried a bit too hard with Americana refs to try and get into that market, but superb songwriting, excellent lyrics and his brother Martin's delicious bass tone await if you YT the full albums of "Swoon" and "Steve McQueen" (which I think was released with a different title in the US).

 
  • Like
Reactions: MonetBass and jerry
Kind of sounds like Robert"Pops" Popwell on the bass

Sounds plenty funky to me

I 'liked' the "my band" response, which I was going to say but - more objective - I also had a stringer job for a UK magazine which had a Liveology column for unsigned band reviews. I saw a lot of bands, and made a point of principle in buying their cassettes if they sold any. So many good live performances, backed up by a dozen or so songs recorded in 8-track or suchlike cheap studios. AFAIK, none of my little reviews gave them more than a small legup. No point in mentioning them all, unless somebody who used to be in either Manchester's The Deckchairs or London (prev Croatia)'s Stella Maris Googles themselves, 20 years later.

Lot of mentions for Gentle Giant but their predecessors Simon Dupree and the Big Sound had a hit with Kites but they hated it and look like they have form for not spreading their legs in the name of success.

Anyways, Doves and Elbow (partic the latter - post "Seldom Seen Kid") have had decent success this side of the pond, but why don't people ever go back to earlier albums? "Lost Souls" and "Asleep in the Back", respectively, are two of the greatest debut albums but with miserable YT views. Do yourself and them a favour:



And Prefab Sprout top my 80s criminally-undersuccessful list (TalkTalk running them close). I think Paddy McAloon tried a bit too hard with Americana refs to try and get into that market, but superb songwriting, excellent lyrics and his brother Martin's delicious bass tone await if you YT the full albums of "Swoon" and "Steve McQueen" (which I think was released with a different title in the US).


Prefab Sprout really takes me back 35 years ago and some friends I used to run with, I still have the vinyl that I haven't revisited in a criminally long time, thanks for that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1bassleft

Latest posts