• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Criminally commercially unsuccessful bands

Kings X is a perfect example in my opinion. Gretchen Goes to Nebraska was f'ing brilliant. But, all the rest of their albums just don't hold up as well.
Did you listen to Dogman?




Out of the Silent Planet?



Granted later albums like Ear Candy and Black Like Sunday are weak spots in the repertoire, but the catalog is strong. Especially the first four albums
 
Gotta disagree a bit about Brand X. For a '70s fusion band they did pretty good. Their second album, Moroccan Roll, actually reached #37 on the UK charts, and #125 in the US. Is There Anything About?, released in 1982, more than two years after they broke up, actually managed to reach #93 on the UK album charts.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: The Owl
Fast Forward was a band that featured Ian Lloyd (former Stories), Bruce Fairbairn, and Jim Vallance along with some other musicians. The group released one album and fell apart with all the players moving on to bigger things.







 
  • Like
Reactions: DJ Bebop
The Beta Band - they were innovative, original and I think they were fecking great, but they self-sabotaged their debut album, never sold records in great numbers and ended up £100,000 in debt to their record company before they split... their 3 E.P's still sounds fresh today...
If "High Fidelity" was not one of my favorite movies, I would have never heard of those guys.
Did you listen to Dogman?




Out of the Silent Planet?



Granted later albums like Ear Candy and Black Like Sunday are weak spots in the repertoire, but the catalog is strong. Especially the first four albums

Tape Head, the eponymous King's X and XV are excellent as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bemo and DJ Bebop
For Wishone Ash lovers like me, the box set Vintage Years 1970 -1991 that was announced near the end of ‘17 is wonderful. I pre-ordered it when it was announced and it arrived a few months later. Very comprehensive with extra goodies. It ain’t cheap (costs more than some Squier basses), but it is still available on Amazon Prime.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DJ Bebop
OK, switching gears to mid 70s brit art-pop, Be Bop Deluxe should've been bigger in the US...


Be Bop Deluxe certainly fit into the "criminally" unsuccessful category.


I just want to say thanks to those on here who rekindled my love for Deluxe. They were in heavy rotation on my table from about ‘76 to ‘80. Not sure why I stopped listening to them. They really should have been huge on this side of the pond. Seventies clothes aside, I think the music holds up really well.

This just popped up recently, very fascinating, of course; "SB" was my favorite album by the band, followed by "Drastic Plastic". "Modern Music", which was the 'big push' album for the US, was kind of a letdown for me, much like how I was nuts over Roxy Music's "Country Life", but felt kinda 'meh' about "Siren". But I gotta tell ya, I think I aged a few years watching the interview...