QUOTE=EADG mx;5037471]I love BTBAM
all of them are untouchable musicians
they're like DT without the cheese[/QUOTE]
I couldn't disagree with this more. It was this quote and the fact that BTBAM are touring with Opeth (amazing) and DT (less amazing than they used to be, but still some of the best stuff ever), that made me purchase Colors.
As a bassist, I was enthralled with Dan Briggs. He's an amazing player and his lines are just amazing (although some parts are carbon copies of riffs on Scenes from a Memory) and I think he's one of the best metal bassists I've ever heard. HOWEVER, the band is just meh... the riffs are impressive... the vocalist is not... at all...
In my opinion, his voice is so crap and the songs are so meandering that the riffs are just that... a collection of cool riffs stuffed into a disc with an untalented vocalist burping all over it.
They are the opposite of Opeth. In Opeth, the music is incredible and when you think (meaning me of course) think that it can't get any better, Akerfelt starts to sing.. and growl or clean.. it takes it to a whole other level. With BTBAM, the music sounds great... and then the vocals start, and I just want to skip the track.
As for the cheese part of the quote, I believe that BTBAM is FAR cheesier than DT for three reasons:
1. The vocalist trying to be so hard core that he sounds like a 13-year-old kid barking about pain, and anger, and other pre-pubescent dreck (even worse than Meshugga) is FAR cheesier than the "wimpy" vocals in DT. Yes, even Lifting Shadows off a Dream.
2. The solos in BTBAM, while technical, often sound like 80-90's videogame music. Petrucci only falls into that during Metropolis Part I.
3. BTBAM often uses the same "silly" interludes in the songs that Jordan Rudess screws up DT songs with. While the western piano in The Dance of Eternity was fun once, Jordan... rein it in please. The "la, la, la, la, lale, la" part and the country/polka parts of Colors is just... cheese... followed by an extra helping of velveta cookie monster vocals.
So for anyone interested in checking out BTBAM, please download a track or two first because while the bassist is amazing, I'd much rather here him with a band with a decent vocalist/songwriting skills.
In a nutshell, BTBAM is currently just a second rate Thought Industry with a first-rate bassist.
-Just my opinion,
Seth