Long story short: at that time I only had 1 bass that needed a Fat Finger, a 4 string jazz w/ a horrible deadspot at the C (5th fret G string). It was so bad that the note's fundamental didn't even ring out, just some muted-sounding harmonics... really strange and so much worse than the 1 other bass I'd had w/ this problem. The BASS Fat Finger fixed the deadspot, and at my amp, I was able to EQ back in the sound I wanted from the bass.
That sounds like my C#. I think I will tell them to put back the neck with the dead spot and try one of those fat fingers.
I have a friend right now that says that's what I get for buying a Squier. I kinda think thats BS though.
Whatever I paid it should work properly or am I deluding mice elf?

I have a bass without dead spots, and really dead roundwounds, no odd EQing, and use no pedals.