• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Disappointed with Fodera

Kind of silly to get all bent because a certain wood combination is no longer available. Here’s just a few sob stories about manufacturers dropping unpopular models over the years.

Fender

Back in the 60s and 70s, Fender used to offer a few dozen “custom colors”. Most old Ps and Js you see, especially pre-CBS ones, are sunburst. They probably shipped 20 or 30 bursts for every custom color order. Today they give you a choice of just 3 or 4 colors and they change them up all the time, with burst and black pretty much always available (but got forbid you want to match the fingerboard wood with the color). When I got an AmStd P5, it was “Candy Cola” with a maple board. Rosewood boards were only offerd that year for bursts and white. The color was red, but not Candy Apple Red, darker. If you wanted Lake Placid Blue, Seafoam Green or CAR, too bad. A few years later the color choices switched and Candy Cola disappeared.

Today’s AmPro II P4 2024 colors are burst, black “Dark Night”, “Miami Blue”, “Mystic Surf Green”, and Olympic White. Burst, black and white come with maple or rosewood boards, but the others are either maple only or rosewood only. The P5 is only in burst/rosewood, dark night/maple, miami blue/maple and white/rosewood.

The 2024 P4 Ultra is sunburst or “Mocha burst" with rosewood board or “Arctic Pearl” (white) with maple board.

The 2024 P4 Performer is Satin Lake Placid Blue with maple board or sunburst or arctic white with rosewood board. No sunburst!

The 2024 P4 Player Plus is “Silver Smoke”/maple, “Olympic Pearl” (white)/pau ferro, Fiesta Red/maple, burst/pau ferro and a lefty (only) in “BelAir Blue”/maple.

The 2024 P4 Player is burst/maple or lefty (only) “Tidal Pool” (blue)/maple. Forget about pau ferro or rosewood.

Wait a year or two and the color/fingerboard choices will change again.

Walter Woods (handbuilt amps)

I was on Walter’s waiting list for 3 years to get a “green light” 450W amp. I checked in with him every year until he told me he was only building the “blue light” 1200W version ($600 more) because not enough people were asking for his other models to bother making circuit boards and ordering the parts. The 100W (“red light”) and 600W (“amber light”) were also on permanent backorder. He told me if I wanted the 1200W in either mono or stereo I could have one in a few weeks, but if I really wanted the 450W I should find a used one. That’s what I did…found one in about two weeks...and Walter has since done a repair for me for free, even though he knew I wasn’t the original owner. He also talked me through a repair that he said was simple enough there was no reason to send it to him.

Steinberger

After Ned sold his company to Gibson they immediately dropped the XP basses. They started selling imported “Spirit” versions of the XL, XM (and later XQ) basses which were all wood and had passive electronics unlike the one piece carbon fiber construction of the XL and the carbon fiber necks of the XM and XQ (all with active electronics). In the mid 90s the carbon fiber models were all discontinued and a new imported wooden Synpase model with carbon fiber stiffeners in the neck arrived. The Synapse and Spirits both disappeared after a few years but a few years ago Gibson started selling Spirits again. The possibility of Gibson ever making carbon fiber Steinberger basses again is probably zero.

Gibson Thunderbird

After being released in 1963 with one pickup (oddly called Thunderbird II) or two pickup (Thunderbird IV) neck-through models (the Firebird guitar models were I, III and V…got it?) they switched to the “non-reverse” body set neck style in 1966 and dropped them in 1969. Most were sunburst, but a number of other colors were offered…blue, red, white, green and maybe others but not black! In 1976, a “bicentennial” non-reverse Tbird IV came out in fewer colors and lasted until 1979. Then nothing until the Tbird IV came back in 1987 but with different pickups and bridge designs, for many years sunburst only but now and then, black, white, red and “heather poly” were offered. Along the way there was a brief period of the Tbird “Studio” with set neck construction and even a short scale model. Not to mention endless variations in the Epiphone lineup and ongoing pickup changes. There was a reissue of the “non-reverse” Tbird IV in 2021 that’s still in the catalog in green, blue and “burgundy” but not burst and the r”reverse” Tbird IV in burst only is officially discontinued but it might come back at any moment…and the saga continues… So if you just want a Tbird II, forget it, be happy with sunburst and if you want a Tbird IV with vintage style pickups and hardware it's only available from Epiphone.
 
  • Like
Reactions: WRM
Do you have experience that leads you to this conclusion? I’ve spoken with and read posts from a number of boutique builders and CNC seems to not multiply production to anywhere near what you are claiming. Also, what is the 12 to 1 comparison based on? What is the other builder using? Just hand tools?
Nyahnyahnyahnyah. It was just a number, and if you think that automation and technology do not increase exponentially productivity you are deluded. Carry on simping for a builder selling basses at the price of a car.
 
i bought a couple of american fenders from SW. i also bought one and returned it with minimum fuss. bought miscellaneous associated gear, too. my guy was matt mckibble. reckon he was good but it's been years. i wised up, only buy used.
 
I learned long ago to not preorder anything from any of the big online music retailers. I’ve been disappointed too many times either by excessive delays in shipping or having my order cancelled later on due to “circumstances beyond our control.”

And it’s not necessarily the dealer’s fault since far too many businesses overpromise and fail to deliver only to shrug it off with nothing more than a casual “oh well.”


Bottom line, I don’t care whose fault (or sometimes lie) it was. Playing the blame game doesn’t fix anything for the customer. So nowadays I don’t preorder anything based on promises like “on order, more arriving soon.” If it isn’t in stock I’ll: (a) wait until it is, (b) change my mind and get something else, or (c) just lose interest and forget about it.
 
Last edited:
Not that any of this is what happened, but some thoughts on what COULD happen. Standards have traditionally been built in runs of 12-15 to make it more affordable than the making of single instruments. What if they had a plan to make them some months away, but with the time approaching, only had 2-3 orders? What if they had the wood ordered, only to have their vender say it's not available? Or the wood was not up to their quality standards? I do know they would pull the plug on a line, rather than build with inferior wood. Just my opinion.
These are all possible, absolutely. Sweetwater should then have personally called the OP, explained, and apologize. Perhaps offer a discount on a Fodera bass in stock.

From what's been posted, I'm guessing there is some shortage of the wood used in that bass (Ivory wood? Whatever that is), or there are some quality issues so Fodera stopped using it. They could have just offered to fill the OP's order with another on-hand wood.
 
I get that some things will become unavailable due to suppliers going out of business or whatever. But if it's a wood combination and they took your money to build the bass, they should honor that two way commitment. If you said, "Nah, I changed my mind", would you get your deposit back? Nope. It should be a two way commitment. And then working out a mutually reasonable agreement if things that are out of their control change over the two year wait.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tjluke
Late last year I contacted Fodera about one of their standard basses. I was advised that they occasionally have some in stock but not presently and the built time was 22 months.
Being an old fart who might not be around to take delivery, I decided to spend a bit extra and get a Yin Yang through Sweetwater.
It wasn’t in stock but they did have some on order so had them place my name on one. This would eliminate over a year of waiting.
Today I received an email from Sweetwater stating that Fodera canceled the order because they decided to discontinue the model I want.
This really ticks me off. I’ve not only lost the year that these have been on order but I’ve also lost the past 6 months since I reserved it.
Sweetwater has no control over what happened. I guess since Fodera’s delivery is out so far, they could care less how they treat potential customers.
That blows, dude. Sorry to hear that.
 
Last edited:
I have my second Fodera and deal fairly often with Sweetwater. I am very interested in seeing what BOTH of them say before I will be
tempted to buy from either of them again. One of them needs to "man up" and take the credit for this incident. I know it's embarrassing for
both of them but taking responsibility and letting the community know which of the parties is to blame is important to me, at least.

Maybe more important is how they, as a team, intend to resolve this for this buyer.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ajkula66
I need to say, I'm pretty disappointed with this thread.

I've came to read a hilarious discussion about someone getting a Fodera and then stating, his Squier isn't any worse.

and all we have is a story about some Fodera dealer that couldn't sell a Fodera bass.
Not to join in with that, but yes, and I’ve never been in a position to buy a bass over $600. I
54. My financial situation is my own problem. lol.

I should say I have had a few beers.

To get back to the point, I wish no one able to buy a fancy bass any harm or ill will. Do it.

I wouldn’t buy any bass made by one of the grail companies from Sweeteater or Guitar Center. Period. I’d go with Reverb or other private sale channels if I tried to buy direct from the manufacturer and they couldn’t fulfill my request.

I don’t speak from experience, of course, as stated above.

I want a Spector Dimension 5 and I will find a non-franchise dealer when I’m ready.

I sympathize with OP but since we are letting our freak flags fly, that’s mine.
 
Hmmm...Is this an anti-SW or an anti-Fodera thread?
Both I guess.

As far as the latter:
I would love to own a Fodera, but couldn't tolerate the wait, let alone spare the $$. Not in these inflationary times.

As far as SW- I didn't know they changed hands. I like what they do, I often get my strings there, and check out the inventories, etc. I will say this tho. IMO- SW should have done something for the OP, I dunno what, but I think that they owe him some due consideration anyway.

As for me- I recently told my SW "Sales Engineer" to take me off the call list. No offense, but I know what I need, and I know what I want. I don't need his help, and if I did ,I'd ask!
I get that they want to make commissions, nothing wrong with that.

Sorry for the OP, Yin-Yangs are tight!
 
  • Like
Reactions: DrThumpenstein

Latest posts