• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Disappointed with Fodera

These are all possible, absolutely

That doesn’t really say anything of substance since anything is possible, right?

Sweetwater should then have personally called the OP, explained, and apologize. Perhaps offer a discount on a Fodera bass in stock.

Why?

Last I heard we’re all presumed innocent until there’s a preponderance of evidence establishing wrong doing in a civil case, or proof of guilt is established beyond reasonable doubt by the evidence in a criminal case.

Saying something is “possible” isn’t proof that was what actually occurred. And speculation isn’t evidence - even if a hundred people jump on the bandwagon. So I wouldn’t be too quick to pass judgement in the absence of facts. :)




Question: did the OP contact Sweetwater directly and talk to anyone about what happened to his order?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: moon-bass
Have you owned and operated a business? I spent 10 years of my life working 16 hours a day having no life running a business I built
Revenue minus expenses equals profit. The variable in that equation is "expenses". They never go down, only up.
Does Fodera use CNC machines? I know he has craftsmen. Betcha they are W2. That means workmen's comp insurance and FICA etc. probably medical and dental too.
Brooklyn rent (or mortgage and taxes).
That can mean you need to build and sell a spitload of $6,000 basses annually to hit profit point. Good tone wood is expensive!
Brady Muckelroy just folded.
Most luthiers can't make it in the long run.
Too expensive, too labor intensive
Owned a small business. Anyway it still stands if your business can’t make money it’s a bad business model. Period. Blaming poor service on profitability is some weak stuff. Granted Fodera isn’t giving the excuse, someone else postulated that. Someone here made an excuse for Fodera, I am merely stating that it’s a BS excuse. If your business can’t fulfill its promise you need to adjust something. If your business is high ticket instruments and you can’t turn a profit even though people are clamoring for your product, there is something wrong with the business model. If you can’t meet demand you stop taking orders.
 
Last edited:
Owned a small business. Anyway it still stands if your business can’t make money it’s a bad business model. Period. Blaming poor service on profitability is some weak stuff. Granted Fodera isn’t giving the excuse, someone else postulated that. Someone here made an excuse for Fodera, I am merely stating that it’s a BS excuse. If your business can’t fulfill its promise you need to adjust something. If your business is high ticket instruments and you can’t turn a profit even though people are clamoring for your product, there is something wrong with the business model. If you can’t meet demand you stop taking orders.
This isn't a Fodera issue it's a Sweetwater error. Sweetwater over promised a product that their service partner (Fodera) had zero ability to fulfill. Vinnie and Joey should reconsider their contract with Sweetwater. Because now it's not Sweetwater with egg on their face...it's Fodera.
 
Last edited:
Wow Ken Smith. Doesn't legend have it that he required you to play a Locrian scale before he would sell a bass to you?? Jk.
I spoke w/ him once at a NAMM and he was pretty cool. Always jonesed for one of his basses; the (old) CR model still has me drooling.
So, if he never built a bass for Spector, what did he do? Accounting? Answer phones? Clean the shop?
Ken- What did he do??:laugh:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lance Bunyon
That doesn’t really say anything of substance since anything is possible, right?



Why?

Last I heard we’re all presumed innocent until there’s a preponderance of evidence establishing wrong doing in a civil case, or proof of guilt is established beyond reasonable doubt by the evidence in a criminal case.

Saying something is “possible” isn’t proof that was what actually occurred. And speculation isn’t evidence - even if a hundred people jump on the bandwagon. So I wouldn’t be too quick to pass judgement in the absence of facts.
But I didn't assign blame or condem any party, neither did the poster I was replying to. They said those things "COULD" happen, and I said it was "possible". I didn't say it was "probable".

And my comment regarding what Sweetwater should do was based on IF they had been at fault ("Sweetwater should THEN..."), so I don't get where you think I passed judgement.

Objectively, your post didn't add any more value than mine. :)
 
The 'white ivory wood' that seems to be the supply issue, is what exactly? Does anyone have the specific wood type? Just curious.

I expect it’s American Holly. It’s pretty uncommon in pieces large enough for instruments that are free of knots. It could be that Fodera’s supply is dwindling. The colour can also vary, so it’s possible that they cannot source an appropriate colour of it.

The Yin Yang standard is available in Mahogany and Purpleheart. I would have hoped that the conversation would have been to switch it to one of those.
 
But I didn't assign blame or condem any party, neither did the poster I was replying to. They said those things "COULD" happen, and I said it was "possible". I didn't say it was "probable".

And my comment regarding what Sweetwater should do was based on IF they had been at fault ("Sweetwater should THEN..."), so I don't get where you think I passed judgement.

Objectively, your post didn't add any more value than mine. :)

I’ll politely disagree, but ok. :)
 
Wow Ken Smith. Doesn't legend have it that he required you to play a Locrian scale before he would sell a bass to you?? Jk.
I spoke w/ him once at a NAMM and he was pretty cool. Always jonesed for one of his basses; the (old) CR model still has me drooling.
So, if he never built a bass for Spector, what did he do? Accounting? Answer phones? Clean the shop?
Ken- What did he do??:laugh:
Locrian is the 7th mode of the major scale.

...I'll see myself out.
 
locrian-mode-on-bass-clef.png
download (1).jpg



NOW: What did Ken Smith do for Spector?
?:mad:
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Lance Bunyon