• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Do you change your playing when you have no drummer ?

Depends on the songs themselves but mostly yes, a bit.

Sometimes more percussive, sometimes more busy to fill in the missing hits.

Sometimes more hold the root to fill the guitar and play with the guitar's rhythm, piano or follow the vocals and just put a bit of a low end cloud out there that their note can ride on to everyone's ears.
 
I play gigs where we sometimes have 4 guitars (2 acoustics, 2 electrics), keys, and drums, and I also play gigs where we have fewer folks - sometimes, keys, drums and me. There are no hard rules about what/how you play when - you get there and play what you need to play to get the feel right. The feel is always different - depends on the other players, the vocalists, etc.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: CaribooBass
Yes and no. My main deal for almost 9 years now has been my drummer-less jazz trio - double bass/saxophone/guitar - and we play a lot of different styles within that setup - not just 4 on the floor swing stuff. I also primarily played jazz duos a lot before that as well. It DEMANDS that your time is as strong as it possibly can be, but it doesn't mean you have to be a quarter note robot. It also doesn't mean that you HAVE to play busier, or more 'percussively' (a.k.a. don't go slapping on a blues or country tune just because there's no drummer). Sonically, you do need to try and occupy a little more space by occasionally playing double-stops to fill out a chord, or maybe a more obvious/pronounced fill here and there, and adjust your tone to be a little 'bigger' vs. fitting in a sonically crowded mix. Use your ears, and listen to what others are doing. If EVERYONE is trying to fill the space that the drummer normally would, it becomes very overbearing.... especially if you have a chunka-chunk guitarist pounding out a rhythm.
 
my biggest nightmare. without the drummer, the others I play with seem to automatically go SLOW. I have to tell them to go faster , or pick up the tempo myself and drive them along. It gets annoying to be the human metronome.

I've experienced this too.... and I solve it by pulling out a metronome in rehearsal and forcing us all to play with it so everyone can feel where they are rushing/dragging.
 
  • Like
Reactions: s van order
To the OP, short answer - yes.

I moved from a large rock band - 3 guitars, drums, keys, multiple singers and me, to a jazz influenced combo of just a singer, a guitarist and me. The main takeaways have been:

1. You are now the timekeeper. The others will naturally look to you to keep everything on-track and together. This means that you will likely need to play a little more simply. Specifically, making sure the "one" is very much on time and pretty much always the root of the chord. You can sometimes do an inversion to keep things interesting, but again, the "one" needs to be there whatever note you play.

2. As the number of instruments decreases, there is good news and bad. The good news is that there is much more sonic space available to you. The bad news is that there is nowhere to hide or be buried in the mix. As such, my advice would be similar to point #1 - play cleanly and correctly, even if it means playing simpler lines.

3. Be present and prepared - there are fewer cues from others to rely on, so you can't go off on your own and expect to hear an obvious signal as to when the music is changing. In many cases, you are the person others are cuing off of. As such, you need to know your parts really well and execute them precisely. You should be doing this anyway, but it's more important in this situation.

4. Embrace the melody. In my case, when the guitar solos, I can comp in a traditional sense, but I can also play a variation of the melody under the solo. This can be helpful to the soloist and others to help provide them with the cues they need (see point #3).

5. If appropriate, you can add in a little slap and pop, but only if it truly fits the song. As another poster suggested, Larry Graham invented this technique because he didn't have a drummer; therefore, it definitely can work, especially on songs that already have slapping. However, it is generally not a good idea to add slapping into songs that don't already feature it, unless you can slap as well as Larry can.

6. Dial you tone into the mix and the room, not what you usually do when practicing alone. This should be something you do anyway (actual tone vs. bedroom tone), but it's even more important when playing without a drummer. You can't be rattling the room and churning out mud when others are depending on you to keep time.

7. Use an 8 string or 12 string sparingly. One other option you may be tempted to use would be an 8 or 12 string bass (the ones with the octave courses). I have tried this a few times with mixed results. On the one hand, using a bass like this makes me simplify my playing, and it fills in some of the sonic space in a smaller group setting. On the other hand, the octave courses usually require a little more drive/distortion to sound good, and they tend to be more audible than the bass strings. As such, they are not always good for helping others keep time. YMMV, but I've found these types of basses better with a drummer and one guitarist situations.

Hope this helps.
 
You said this was for church. So I assume you are doing semi modern worship tunes. The bass parts on thise tunes are sometimes just whole or half notes with no real bass line to play. With no drummer you are now responsible for keeping the tempo correct. You will have to change what you play in order to do that. Especially if your other band mates are not advanced enough players, which happens a lot in church worship teams. Sometimes it's as simple as playing an extra pick up note to the 1. Sometimes you need to create a moving part that establishes tempo but doesn't overshadow the other players. It can actually be great fun if you think about it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CaribooBass
In the Summer our Worship Teams often do not have some one around to fill in for them. As a result we do not as I mentioned have a drummer this Sunday.

Have any of you been in this position before and what did you change or add to your playing or your Bass?

Thanks
Clayton

For me no, the only thing I would change is how much warmth is in my tone. But playing wise it would be the same. This keeps you fresh for when a drummer is present and requires less effort to get adjustedZ
 
Yes. As others have said, you are now the sole time keeper. If I can come up with a groove that covers the kick and snare hits as well as outlining the changes, home run! In most cases that becomes too busy. My main focus is the time, feel and changes. If the guitarist is good they can add the snare accents.

When this happens I feel like then I have to really earn my money, either actually or figuratively. It's really not much different than playing with a poor drummer, in fact maybe easier. I sat in at a friends band rehearsal when their bass player couldn't make it. I knew most of the songs so not a big deal. I knew the drummer was the weak link but didn't realize how bad until we started. We got through it and had a good rehearsal but honestly, I needed a drink after that. I worked HARD! I commented to the bass player next time I saw him that I didn't realize how much of the load he carried at gigs. He just smiled and nodded. Not long after that drummer got an attitude and quit the band. They replaced him with a better drummer and wow, what a difference. They took a major leap forward as a band.

I play guitar and bass at church sometimes too. I learn the songs with the recordings but make sure someone could guess the song (if they were familiar with it) when I played my part by myself.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CaribooBass
I try my best to avoid playing without a drummer. Acoustic trios and the like are just no-fun zones for me. That probably has something to do with the fact that it's where I started out 40+ years ago and it feels like I'm back in the starting gate when I play without a drummer.

That said, on the occasions I have to do it, I am sure my playing is different, because I'm not focusing on locking in with the drums, but rather on keeping the tempo steady and laying down a simpler groove that supports a sparser arrangement.