• TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
    Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
    Join freeLog in
    Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.

Does a great BASS make a great BASS player

Did he still sound like himself on a P bass?
Sure did. I was just sort of suprised how effortlessly he made the switch look. He's played Jazz basses before, but those have thin necks too. For me some of the Primus stuff is horribly difficult to play on thicker necks (at least when you play it the way he does). And he just effortlessly plays that stuff on a P neck.
 
  • Like
Reactions: poochiecheeks
I've known too many intermediate Bass players that bought a really expensive great Bass .
and many great BASS players that bought a decent Bass for a few hundred dollars that played and sounds like a expensive one.
A great BASS will not make a great BASS player
A great BASS player can make a just okay BASS play and sound like a great BASS.

agree ?
Disagree ?
Agree.
 
I'm the cat who's never paid more than $400 for a bass, which means I read threads like this to see what I'm missing out on. I have some really wonderful basses that are a joy to play, but I'm always curious about what a "really good bass" could bring out, or encourage, in my playing.

What I love about playing different basses is that each one seems to have a thing that it wants to do; a place where it really shines. Sometimes, I can't get a certain groove right on one bass, so I reach for the one that might be a step ahead of me. I could see a very well-made bass offering up more room to discover what you can do. If I only stuck to one bass, I don't know that I would push my boundaries as much. I'm not sure if that's an argument for one great bass or not, but I sure would like to play around with a few "great" basses at some point! Maybe not when they are economically out of reach, though.
The big thing you're missing out on with cheap basses is the varity. Every now and then you get a bass with specs that are just heavenly. But that's difficult to find among the cheaper basses, because the manufacturers of those tend to hang onto the original designs that are most popular.
That's why I think the only real way to really get your dream bass when you're on a budget, is to build one yourself. The tools might be an investment, but once you have them, every new instrument is essentially just a bit of material cost and opportunity cost. And opportunity cost starts to seem very affordable, when the alternative is to work for extra money so you could afford that dream bass from someone else.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rev_Slinky
Does a great BASS make a great BASS player?

14211.gif


:)
 
An expensive, pro-quality bass won't make you a better bassist (practice will), but Victor Wooten did say that a good instrument is an investment in yourself.

Plus, people are judgy. You see a musician with an expensive instrument, you expect them to be good. You see a musician with a flashy looking instrument, you expect them to be charismatic on stage.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DJ Bebop
I've known too many intermediate Bass players that bought a really expensive great Bass .
and many great BASS players that bought a decent Bass for a few hundred dollars that played and sounds like a expensive one.
A great BASS will not make a great BASS player
A great BASS player can make a just okay BASS play and sound like a great BASS.

agree ?
Disagree ?
Why does anyone care about what anyone else is playing? Different people can afford different basses, different people play at a different skill level. At the end of the day, it should be about the individual….”are you enjoying what you are doing and are you having fun”. It’s not a competition.
If you’re a great player, build up those learning, help them to continue to grow, encourage them. Definitely don’t rip them if they are playing a nice bass.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SuperTheBass
Once you find the one great bass you can fully commit to, you can finally stop wasting your time searching for the perfect bass online and instead work on becoming a better player.
I want to commit to one bass. I spend too much time a/b’ing basses/switching basses. I love my G&L L-1000 and think it would be the perfect number one for me. My Sadowsky and Serek think otherwise. The saga continues
 
Nope. A good player can (usually) make it work on something cheap and still sound great. A better instrument MAY help you to play better but it's not going to magically infuse you with talent. As has been said, an instrument - regardless of price - will inspire. An expensive instrument is also not necessarily good as a given - it has to work for the player. There are many basses that would not work for me at any price. Way, way too many variables at play here.
 
Nope. A good player can (usually) make it work on something cheap and still sound great. A better instrument MAY help you to play better but it's not going to magically infuse you with talent. As has been said, an instrument - regardless of price - will inspire. An expensive instrument is also not necessarily good as a given - it has to work for the player. There are many basses that would not work for me at any price. Way, way too many variables at play here.
For example, if we see a great of bass like Charles Berthoud who has small hands, we realize that he could not shred on anything with a baseball bat neck, even a 5K FCS. (He could obviously still play any song most of us can play)
 
not about bass, but...

when we'd go to music stores, i could always find my husband because not only do i recognize his guitar style, but i recognize the tone he dials in. cheap, expensive or in between bass or gear, he always sounds like him. i expect the same is true of me.

that being said, some basses are just easier to play, making it easier to do what you are trying to do, but they're not always the most expensive basses.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sauron_ and JRA

Latest posts