well ive found living in scotland theres nearly no music scene that isnt a cover band or a so-so metal band
theres a bigger scene in edinburgh (i call it edsbra) but its really expencive there compered to glasgow and you dont really get paid for meny gigs here
Can't say I agree with that at all.
There is a pretty large alternate scence, be it from indie, rock, punk or metal (or whatever else). Glasgow certainly has a bigger "scene" that Edinburgh, you also get most of the better big gigs

.
I live in Edinburgh, Scotland. Its cold, wet and I think the whole city has forgotten how to be happy. Its amazing how you can walk from a hugely affluent area into a much poorer area with ease. Oh and as I said earlier, its cold and wet.
While generally true of most of Scotland, we have had some decent days this past week. Went up Arthurs Seat with the missues a week back, good times!
Also, I wouldn't say it is entirely proped up by students, Dundee was far worse for it IME. Tho, the tourists are a pain. On the brighter side, we do get the festival, even tho that's been pretty bleak the last couple years.
I'd like to think, instead of our history bringing interest, out compeltelly incompetant council does a better job. f-ing trams, but I digress!
I dare say I kind of fall into the student catagorey, tho it does involve working 50 weeks a year and a monthly pay check. So maybe I'm biased!
I'd say the biggest problem with the music scene in Edinburgh is probably the lack of advertising. I tend to only find out about gigs by word of mouth.
Its not impossible. You can empty your wallet down George Street and beyond if you fancy. I was at a gig last night at a venue called Voodoo rooms, and a few uptempo Glasgow (ha!) bands were playing, and the audience just stood and watched them like they were down the art gallery.
Aw man, just avoid George Street, other than the Standing Order (which, is only fun for watching a game in a crowded atmosphere), George Street is just a rip and a waste of time. Not to mention your average George Street goer tends to look down thier noses at everyone!