Enjoy the benefits of a premium membership!
Upgrade Account
-
TalkBass has been independent since 1998. Add your voice.
Create a free account to reply to discussions, view embedded media, and browse with fewer display ads.
Join free Log in
Want zero display ads or expanded classifieds tools? Compare plans.
Ever get a bad string?
- Thread starter joelns
- Start date
Only once in about 20 years of playing. The .115 string in a DR DDT set I use for C# standard on a four string. Have probably bought that set about 10 times with no issues. However this time I tried to tune the brand new string to C#(1 1/2 steps below E) like I always do and the tuner just kept showing E even when tightening the string. Felt some resistance then SNAP! Emailed DR and had a new string in a couple days that tuned up just fine.
Ric5
Inactive
- Jan 29, 2008
- 29,772
- 30,452
- Disclosures
- I like 5, 8, 10, and 12 string basses
I used to get dead strings right out of the package ... with several brands ... now I use D'Addario and that stopped ... I don't remember having a string that will not intonate
The SuperBrights had a major QC issue a few years back…there’s even a thread on the matter from bygone days. To shut me up, Dunlop sent me a carton each of the SS and nicks. I rarely change my strings and just recently installed the last remaining set.
Riis
DR - Hi Beams Low B (slighty dead out of the paclage, totally dead in 2 days)
DR - Dragon Skin G (dead out of the package, but the rest of the set really was a pleasant surprise... )
Dean Markley - Blue Steel D (this was unusable. The wound was a lot thinner between the third and fourth frets, and it was not possible to bring it to pitch)
I like new zingy strings and change it quite often, so I would say that 3 strings in 10 years is not that bad
DR - Dragon Skin G (dead out of the package, but the rest of the set really was a pleasant surprise... )
Dean Markley - Blue Steel D (this was unusable. The wound was a lot thinner between the third and fourth frets, and it was not possible to bring it to pitch)
I like new zingy strings and change it quite often, so I would say that 3 strings in 10 years is not that bad
about 3 years ago i got a set of black beauties and the D string just snapped when i got it close to tuned. never happend before in 22 years. GC just gave me an entire new set of strings and they worked great
Impressive! I gave up on a certain string manufacturer as I got duff E strings consistently across 3 or 4 new sets....
A couple duds in a row ended my love thing with Rotosound.
Stuff happens, and the store did help me out. But the three trips to the store thing did it for me.
I order all my strings from Fret Nation now, and have a pile of new strings and used spares. If I ever get another dud, I’m sure Jason will make it right. Great service, selection, pricing, and free shipping at FretNation.com.
Stuff happens, and the store did help me out. But the three trips to the store thing did it for me.
I order all my strings from Fret Nation now, and have a pile of new strings and used spares. If I ever get another dud, I’m sure Jason will make it right. Great service, selection, pricing, and free shipping at FretNation.com.
I had 2 sets of Dean Markley in a row with a bad string back when those were a thing and then i was over blue steels.
devnulljp
Supporting Member
Yeah, once in 45+years of playing. I guess it happens. La Bella customer service sent me another in the mail, so no foul.
Yes. But over 50+ years of keeping fresh round wounds on my basses, maybe 3.
I may have ruined one or two flats during the installation process. After reading the helpful posts on the subject here on this board, it is highly doubtful I will make the same mistakes.
I'd say getting a bad string is fairly rare.
I've been playing bass since I was 15. I'm 44 now. I've also had near lifeling string GAS (I call it string-pokemon- gotta try 'em all) so I've had more strings than an Old English Sheepdog's had fleas.
I've only had one string be totally dead out of the package (an E-string in a D'Addario set) but their customer service made it right. I won't go on a tirade about D'Addario because I simply dodged a bullet elsewhere. GHS, Ernie Ball, DR, Dunlop, etc. every make will have a dud once in a million. My one dead string could have been from any maker. It's a low percentage and it sucks when you're the unlucky one. So, like everyone else, I stick with brands that have good customer service.
D'Addario are still my favorite/preferred strings.
I've only had one string be totally dead out of the package (an E-string in a D'Addario set) but their customer service made it right. I won't go on a tirade about D'Addario because I simply dodged a bullet elsewhere. GHS, Ernie Ball, DR, Dunlop, etc. every make will have a dud once in a million. My one dead string could have been from any maker. It's a low percentage and it sucks when you're the unlucky one. So, like everyone else, I stick with brands that have good customer service.
D'Addario are still my favorite/preferred strings.
Last edited:
Long time ago I bought 2 sets of TI 344 Jazz Rounds, both with a bad A string. The dealer replaced them with minimal bother.
I'll definitely check them out! I've been using D'Addario Chromes with very good results, but I did get a dead B-string most recently, which has me looking once again.
Years ago I got a pack of Fender rounds and the A string was rough and corroded. It was like it rusted in the pack. The other strings were perfect. Very very weird.
IIRC they sent me a new set of strings. Over the years I have had very good customer service and attentiveness when it comes to strings.
IIRC they sent me a new set of strings. Over the years I have had very good customer service and attentiveness when it comes to strings.
Had only once D'Addario black tapes. It actually played but had a cosmetic flaw. They sent me a new pack when all I asked was a new string and when I un-winded the A string the tape unraveled. They asked if I could send that string to them for further investigation
Good company to deal with, but DR (guitar strings) was the same as well as well as Evan's drum heads
Good company to deal with, but DR (guitar strings) was the same as well as well as Evan's drum heads
Once in the late 90's. I had bought a short scale set of coated strings (maybe Elixir, but I'm not sure) and the included E string was clearly a long scale one and I couldn't use it (the silk end was past the nut and almost at the first fret). Music store didn't want to exchange it since they were jerks (and I'm glad they don't exist anymore). I called customer support, left a message, still waiting for them to get back to me. Might be any day now.
This was a 50$ set of strings back then. Went back to Rotos since that's what Geddy played anyway.
This was a 50$ set of strings back then. Went back to Rotos since that's what Geddy played anyway.
Sounds like it happens regardless of brand. 2 time with DR for me. One wouldnt stay tuned up and another had a rattle sound like it was vibrating against something, athough I believe it was loose windings.
